Přeskočit obsah

Corpus Deliberation Review Claims v1

Source schema: doc/schemas/corpus-deliberation-review-claims.v1.schema.json

Optional profile-bound structural artifact for thematic review profiles only. The general/default Corpus profile remains prose exchange on an arbitrary topic through plain-text or Markdown, including inert code fragments, and does not require a claim envelope. This artifact is used only by a review boundary that explicitly adopts it; it is not a domain ontology, a global profile registry, or a mandatory claim format for every technical, scientific, social, or creative workflow. Operators and communities may propose versioned profiles, while each receiving host admits them under local policy; federation endorsement may provide evidence but cannot compel local admission. The admitted profile owns vocabulary, admissibility, evidence or evaluation semantics, success criteria, disposition mapping, and legal next moves; their opaque namespaced refs remain open and are not centrally enumerated by this schema. Schema-valid references alone do not prove profile support or readiness: automatic machine consumption requires a separately admitted versioned profile.

Governing Basis

Project Lineage

Fixtures

Valid Fixtures

Invalid Fixtures

Fields

Field Required Shape Description
schema yes const: corpus-deliberation-review-claims.v1
profile/ref yes ref: #/$defs/ref Opaque namespaced reference to semantics proposed and owned outside this envelope. Automatic machine consumption requires the receiving host to have separately admitted that exact versioned operator- or community-defined profile, which then owns the meaning and validation of every other opaque reference in this artifact. Federation endorsement may inform local policy but cannot compel admission.
disposition/ref yes ref: #/$defs/ref Opaque namespaced profile-owned review disposition. The generic envelope neither enumerates it nor maps it to a verdict or outcome.
claims yes array Profile-interpreted structural claims. An empty set is valid at the generic layer when the selected profile permits it.
next-move yes unspecified Optional profile-owned structural suggestion using opaque namespaced refs. It carries no execution, publication, or adjudication authority.
commentary yes array Bounded inert provenance commentary. A profile MUST NOT derive its disposition, verdict, next move, or effect authority from this text.

Definitions

Definition Shape Description
ref string
claim object Closed structural claim tuple whose reference vocabulary and admissibility remain owned by the selected profile.
next-move object Closed, inert prospective move interpreted and authorized only by the selected profile and its downstream owner.
## Field Semantics

schema

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: const: corpus-deliberation-review-claims.v1

profile/ref

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: ref: #/$defs/ref

Opaque namespaced reference to semantics proposed and owned outside this envelope. Automatic machine consumption requires the receiving host to have separately admitted that exact versioned operator- or community-defined profile, which then owns the meaning and validation of every other opaque reference in this artifact. Federation endorsement may inform local policy but cannot compel admission.

disposition/ref

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: ref: #/$defs/ref

Opaque namespaced profile-owned review disposition. The generic envelope neither enumerates it nor maps it to a verdict or outcome.

claims

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: array

Profile-interpreted structural claims. An empty set is valid at the generic layer when the selected profile permits it.

next-move

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: unspecified

Optional profile-owned structural suggestion using opaque namespaced refs. It carries no execution, publication, or adjudication authority.

commentary

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: array

Bounded inert provenance commentary. A profile MUST NOT derive its disposition, verdict, next move, or effect authority from this text.

Definition Semantics

$defs.ref

  • Shape: string

$defs.claim

  • Shape: object

Closed structural claim tuple whose reference vocabulary and admissibility remain owned by the selected profile.

$defs.next-move

  • Shape: object

Closed, inert prospective move interpreted and authorized only by the selected profile and its downstream owner.