Contextual Whisper authorship¶
Status: accepted phase-1 design; bounded Gate A/B qualified 2026-11-04. Historical checkpoints below keep their original results; broader scopes remain separate. Date: 2026-10-25. Based on: P015, P013, P081-021, S017 and S023.
Executive summary¶
Phase 1 counts council-admitted participant sources within one rumor context and epoch. Multiple nyms, certificates or transport nodes do not increase one source's contribution. This profile supersedes the node-counting M4 rule only for the new v2 artifacts. Historical M4 evidence retains its original scope.
Gate A qualifies private certification and erasure independently of Matrix. Gate B qualifies real host/Vault authorship and contextual thresholds on SQLite and unmodified Synapse. Neither gate proves unique humans, an honest council, anonymous transport, federation, or complete Whisper readiness.
Measured closeout (2026-11-04)¶
P015-001--003 and both bounded runtime gates are qualified: A30/30, B31/31,
plus six separate C conformance obligations. Clean qualifier edd7b895d rechecks
6,877 original source files and 5,351 observations. Loose, archive-extracted and
fresh primary/secondary results are identical. The operator-only retained set
has 6,369,295 B at XZ128MiB; compact path-free Git controls stay below64KiB.
Full result, source genealogy, receipts and exclusions.
This is a reviewed composition of exact original runtime/capture/verifier sources,
not a new single-binary recapture. Council policy, AD admission, host consent,
trusted publication time and eligibility remain distinct decisions. Real SQLite
and pinned unmodified Synapse qualify ordinary confidence0.5 host/Vault/UI,
source counts, status/expiry/reset, restart/replay, privacy and required full PDUs.
Matrix runtime uses authenticated-admitted-homeserver-v1; full-PDU verification
is acceptance evidence, not a portable runtime time proof. The owner-selected
image-backup fixture opt-in does not extend controlled-copy erasure to retained
keystore/image backups. Optional stay-ready runtime, P015-004/005, P081's other
consumers, Anon, federation, full Whisper/global Agora and release readiness are
excluded. No large evidence withdrawal was performed. Unknown hold/dependency/
minimum-retention coverage remains protected. Historical refusals are unchanged.
Context and problem¶
Before this slice, the certificate verifier and historical acceptance nym signer did not provide an ordinary participant's issuance, signing and renewal path. Transport admission, certification policy, permission to sign and eligibility to count are four different decisions. The optional issuer service owns policy and decisions; the host owns private nym keys; AD owns delivery of already encrypted bytes.
The host bounds each AD submission by the adopted profile's request TTL. This is a transport lifetime covering discovery, exact invitation consent and retry, not the duration of one scheduler pass. AD preserves the first submission's bytes, plan and expiry on retry. This budget neither extends the signed request or certificate nor grants late issuance; the original domain and consent validity checks remain decisive. A retained result uses its separately bounded readback/consent contract.
Knowledge minimization and participant agency require bounded private mappings, explicit renewal consent and no public reset linkage. Reproducibility requires immutable admission decisions and a separate current eligibility projection.
ADC auxiliary request development checkpoint (2026-11-17)¶
nym-issuance-request.v2 now admits an optional, closed scope/auxiliary-uses
array containing exactly one ADC audience-manifest tuple: (whisper-release,
whisper-embargo-audience-manifest.v1, exact topic/key, single-audience,
embargo-audience-manifest). The signed request must select it explicitly, its
topic must match the request, and the adopted profile must contain the complete
tuple. Missing selection grants no ADC use; null, empty, multiple, wildcard or
broadened selections refuse. Predecessor publication and LLR manifest policy is
unchanged; this child scope does not implement the complete P015-005 design.
The issuer no longer copies ADC permissions from the profile without that selection. Applicant verification rejects an overgrant or undergrant even with valid certificate and decision signatures. The existing signing domains cover the selection. Exact tuple membership is shared with manifest-use verification; no independent-list Cartesian product or authority inferred from labels is added.
Real issue/open/restart/exact-replay component tests use the fenced key store with explicitly simulated media policy. They neither qualify native custody nor the combined protected S026 signing/preparation and ADC release path. The P015-005-ADC child and parent remain todo. Older experimental replies violating the new request binding refuse; frozen historical evidence and qualifiers retain their exact sources and scope. See the Node boundary.
The actual applicant/Vault owner now accepts the same bounded selection through its existing local prepare command. It checks local Import Gate, adopted-profile membership, topic and exchange phase before opening custody or minting, binds the selection into the frozen intent and all signed request proofs, and compares it again on protected-state recovery. Changing that selection under an existing operation id conflicts. Readback v2 exposes the requested scope, separately from the certificate's granted authority; ordinary operations omit it.
Actual Vault-store component tests cover reopen/exact bytes and no extra mint, plus refusal without a new applicant candidate or changed Vault. They retain the existing recovery-current gate; the explicit export marker is simulated in the fixture and does not qualify the operator ceremony/native custody. This is a source-client prerequisite, not complete all-or-none M/M_A authoring or release execution. P015-005-ADC and ADC-005 remain todo and historical scope is unchanged.
The ordinary protected authoring preview additionally consumes that granted M_A tuple for explicit private ADC source consent. It freezes independent openings before review, binds C_M into the same source and persists all signed M_A with the signed source before response. This remains source-owner component coverage: complete-consent transfer to S026, native issuance/custody and full ADC execution are unqualified. It does not close P015-005-ADC; see the source contract.
Decisions¶
Source profile and ordering¶
whisper-source-profile.v1 is content addressed using JCS, with NFC required
before signing. The context is the JCS digest of federation, exact profile digest,
council identity, topic class and similarity key. The digest is not a secret.
A public certificate carries its opaque source reference, profile/context,
epoch, signed activation/not-before and stable status/min-revision = 1.
The profile requires source/activation-policy = post-reset-collection-drain-v1,
so adopting this correction changes its content digest. It carries no participant, source node,
request/reply reference or private predecessor.
Production epochs are half-open seven-day intervals anchored at
1970-01-05T00:00:00Z. Certificates last at most 24 hours and end no later than
the epoch. Every certificate uses a fresh context-confined nym key. Routine
renewal retains the source; private reset changes it and revokes the previous
source without publishing a successor. Distinct epochs never combine.
The council knows which participant requested each rumor context and when. Public similarity keys can reveal the meaning of a context digest. Phase 1 trusts its uniqueness policy and accepts this participation/timing disclosure. The council is a dependency for a first context and for certificate renewal; an already usable certificate does not need a fresh issuance round trip. Acceptance records the complete request-to-decision latency, not just AD ACK.
Notice and embargo manifest scope extension¶
Planned post-MVP (2026-10-28), owned by
P015-005.
The current signal-only profile does not authorize correlation notices or
separately signed embargo manifests. Its replacement/extension must bind exact
(record/kind, schema, topic, disclosure/scope) tuples; independent kind, schema
and topic arrays must never produce an implicit Cartesian product of grants.
Issuance and receiving-side verification both enforce the tuple and the issuer's
admitted profile. Unsupported profiles refuse instead of silently downgrading.
The manifest is a separately domain-bound auxiliary signing use, explicitly listed by this profile, with the same certified key/context and authenticated admission-time bounds. It does not grant a new publication kind. The full protected signal references its digest; the admission receipt binds the two. The recipient verifies the manifest and receipt without retrieving that signal. This does not let a detached signature stand in for the full envelope signature. P015-005 owns positive and cross-kind/cross-scope refusal fixtures; ADC-001/007 own application use. None of this expands the existing narrow signal-only profile or qualifies Gate B.
Unpublished Matrix preparation¶
Ordinary v2 publication first checks current contextual authorship/status and
freezes an exact transport intent. 202 publication-requested and a later
forwarding ACK are not admitted domain records. The intent creates no source,
publication-time fact or receiving nonce. Authenticated reception independently
supplies the admitted homeserver observation and commits admission. Status and
retry remain available by their topic-authorized links before the record exists.
A first intent must be prepared before its signed proof deadline. Retry preserves the original bytes and transaction identity; it never extends validity or promises that a late event will pass admission. Historical readback needs no new status lease. Frozen intent/carrier/mode/transaction conflicts refuse. Explicit legacy v1 has no contextual publisher fallback. This owner composition is software implementation, not completed ordinary UI, Synapse or Gate B qualification.
Publication time and status freshness¶
Certificate, request and presentation validity are checked at an authenticated
publication time, with five seconds of skew. authored/at is never that proof.
The receiving relay must first admit the record strictly before epoch end; skew
does not extend an epoch. A publication time after local receipt plus skew is
refused. A valid certificate can therefore expire before history reaches C.
The immutable profile binds publication/matrix-time-policy =
authenticated-admitted-homeserver-v1 and publication/sqlite-time-policy =
signed-admitted-relay-receipt-v1; changing either policy changes the profile
digest. This draft refinement invalidates no released certificate or Gate A/B
result, because those runtime gates are not yet qualified.
For Matrix, the phase-1 policy explicitly trusts origin_server_ts supplied
by the configured, independently admitted homeserver over an authenticated
Client-Server connection. The trusted network adapter binds that observation to
the account, room, event, sender and exact author bytes; a timestamp inside the
carrier or author document cannot supply it. Persist this backend observation
with admission for restart/replay. No author timestamp, unsigned relay stamp or
unadmitted server is a fallback clock authority.
This is authenticated homeserver-time evidence, not runtime verification of a
server-signed full PDU. Full-PDU hashes/signatures/size remain independent
acceptance evidence. Matrix supports federation-format events through a /sync
filter, but this policy does not require that optional runtime verifier or a
Server-Server API identity. Neither TLS authentication nor an event signature
establishes an objective clock or an honest homeserver. The operator accepts the
named server's clock for this phase; the fixture's explicit isolated loopback
HTTP channel is a fixture-only trust profile, never a production TLS substitute.
Phase-1 reaffirmation (2026-10-28): the observation is a local replayable fact,
not a portable time attestation for another node. A later runtime PDU verifier
is a separate explicit profile behind the existing publication-evidence port.
Its missing or invalid PDU must not silently select this observation policy.
The required time policies and source/activation-policy =
post-reset-collection-drain-v1 remain part of the profile identity; no default
or schema omission may erase those decisions.
For SQLite use an allowlisted relay's signed durable admission receipt binding record digest, exact author-byte digest, relay identity and acceptance time. Receipt verification precedes construction of publication-time evidence.
A signed, scope-bound status snapshot is usable for collecting a signal for at
most 3600 seconds. A status older than 300 seconds marks the current basis as
freshness=unknown and cannot authorize the first threshold/proposal emission.
The two limits are explicit profile fields, never added to clock tolerance.
Missing/stale status is deferred, not a permanent rejection. Revocations are
cumulative within the epoch; signed rollback and same-revision equivocation
refuse. Every change to a signed status payload, including refreshed timestamps, uses
a new revision. Durable high-water marks survive restart and rebuild. Public
certificates use the profile/epoch's stable status floor, not a per-request or
per-reset revision that would identify a revoked predecessor. The private
issuance decision binds the actual minimum publication revision. Eligibility
and the emission latch commit under the same status-revision CAS. Imported
claims cannot replace local eligibility or first-emission facts.
On 2026-10-26 the operator accepted an activation quarantine for private reset. The replacement source cannot be used while any status from before the reset could still be admitted under the collection lease. The binding retains this activation boundary through renewal, restart and another node's request. The certificate's earliest tolerated publication time must be no earlier than that boundary; subtracting the five-second certificate tolerance must not create an overlap. A reset too late to leave a nonempty certificate interval before epoch end refuses explicitly. It does not silently activate, carry the contribution to another epoch or fall back to the predecessor. The fixture uses its own short collection lease; this proves the same boundary, not a one-hour runtime observation. This replaces the earlier per-reset public-revision barrier.
Let U be the greatest collection expiry of every published status before the
reset. Choose the replacement certificate's not-before >= U + 5 seconds.
Both its trusted publication anchor and actual local reception must satisfy
that lower validity bound with at most the same five-second tolerance. Testing
only the publication anchor would apply the future-publication allowance a
second time and permit an early local admission. At the earliest permitted
local receipt r = U, the old collection lease (r < U) has already ended.
Public validity timestamps still permit temporal inference; this profile does
not claim timing anonymity or hide the council's contemporaneous knowledge.
A deferred live admission preserves its first-receipt time but evaluates current status, revocations and epoch closure at the actual decision time. It cannot borrow the receipt's older clock to refresh status or admit after epoch end. Retained facts distinguish publication, first receipt and admission; clock rollback refuses. This is separate from replaying an already committed decision.
Previously accepted contributions survive natural certificate expiry, but cease to count after source revocation or epoch end. Historical admission facts do not change during replay; replay verifies their stored proof and policy identity, not today's clock. The current view uses the current verified status separately.
The narrow P081 bridge keeps request audience agora-ingest and a one-shot
presentation bound to the exact unsigned Agora candidate. Its certificate has
the fixed whisper-contextual-authorship audience and rumor-context digest.
Only the concrete verified whisper-signal.v2 profile bridges these contexts;
this is not a generic audience rewrite. Outer and presentation certificates must
be byte-equivalent under JCS and identify the same certified nym/source.
The presentation's revocation/evidence-ref is a stable scope locator:
nym-source-status-scope: followed by base64url SHA-256 of the JCS object with
schema = nym-source-status-scope.v1, profile/digest, issuer/id,
context/digest and epoch. It is not a snapshot or freshness lease. The owner
fetches and verifies the current signed scope status independently. No complete
revocation inventory is copied into each author envelope. P081 possession and
certificate validity use the independently trusted publication anchor; nonce
reservation uses actual local reception and remains through epoch end. Signal
preview/signing uses the collection lease, while the separate first aggregate
emission requires the stricter emission lease.
Renewal, preview and first emission¶
Renewal is lazy by default, when the participant next publishes in the context.
Optional stay-ready consent covers exactly one context until epoch end, is
revocable and permits at most seven renewals. The scheduler chooses and persists
a random time in 75–95 percent of the current validity interval. It does nothing
when the next certificate cannot extend validity within the epoch. Unlock and
current recovery-bundle requirements remain in force; there is no autoexport.
The host reserves a bounded renewal-operation slot and persists its exact time
and operation id before effects. Re-reading that plan does not redraw time or
spend another slot; uncertain/aborted effects do not silently refund allowance.
Revocation fences future effects while retaining an already reserved operation
for factual decision reconciliation. Late completion cannot revive consent or
count across an epoch boundary. A replacement consent needs a separate explicit
approval; the host enforces one active consent per participant/context/epoch.
All updates retain source authority and CAS.
Operation IDs make nym preparation and preview idempotent. A 423 retains the exact document; an expired preview requires a new explicit preview.
The first crossing freezes authority, descriptor, inputs, time and signing bytes
under (profile, context, epoch, kind, authority). Later revocation/reset changes
the current basis and a proposal's read-model annotation (eligible,
below-threshold, freshness-unknown, epoch-ended). It neither edits a signed
proposal nor emits another first-crossing event. This is an authority-qualified
current annotation, not a globally distributed retraction artifact.
Private exchange and authority¶
Use nym-issuance-request.v1 and nym-issuance-decision.v1. The exact signed
request digest identifies the idempotent domain decision inside erasable
custody. A separately random ExchangeHandle (exchange: plus canonical
base64url of 32 random bytes) identifies transport; it is not derived from that
digest, a participant, nym, nonce, context or source. Bind applicant proof,
proof of the new nym key, an independent ephemeral bootstrap proof, council,
permitted reply recipient, operation, nonce and deadline. Requests expire within 15 minutes and before epoch end.
Persist the decision and prepared reply before AD sends it. Readback by request
reference never repeats issuance. Duplicate delivery returns the retained result.
Council admission is an explicit P015 policy. A federation root does not grant council certification authority. A separate root-admitted capability-issuance key can authorize exact, bounded request/reply INAC invitations for ordinary participants. This P076 bootstrap profile grants neither Messaging permissions, sovereignty nor onward delegation. AD receipt is not a council decision.
P015 plaintext is encrypted to the authorized recipient before entering AD; AD stores ciphertext and opaque references only. No general AD custody hook is introduced. The issuer's recipient key for identifying exchange material must be erasable with that exchange/binding. Encrypting archived requests to a permanent council key would defeat erasure and is forbidden for this profile. Signed recipient-key offers and invitations bind the exchange, recipient, key and deadline. Applicant reply custody remains with that applicant. Reset-linking request/reply material uses a separate disposable transition key, not the new binding's surviving key. Existing X25519/HKDF and XChaCha20-Poly1305 primitives are reused with explicit purpose and AAD; no new cryptographic construction.
Erasure and keystore¶
application-keystore-v1 stores one independently random secret per key file,
outside DB/WAL, application backups, logs and retained evidence. Each context/epoch permits at most 2048 issued certificates, including renewals
and replacements. Reserve this quota before effects, including the capacity to
revoke all issued certificates/sources. Cumulative status arrays allow 4096
entries each; retirement does not replenish issuance quota. Their public signed
status has a separate 512 KiB canonical-JSON byte ceiling, sufficient for both
full inventories. This does not raise the private P015 plaintext (64 KiB), sealed
exchange (96 KiB), Agora envelope or Matrix PDU budgets. The active plus
retiring key cap is separately 4096; capacity refusal precedes minting or issuance effects.
The provider pins its instance and encrypted volume. Missing mount is a typed
refusal, never directory creation on an underlying unencrypted filesystem.
Keys are not derivable from a retained master, epoch seed or mnemonic.
The local encrypted-image custody default requires backup exclusions. The owner
subsequently permits an explicit acceptance-fixture adoption
custody.image_backup_policy = "allow-encrypted-image-backups". An encrypted
sparseimage/sparsebundle on unexcluded backing storage may then pass preflight,
including when macOS automatically reports its mounted contents excluded. Preserve
both actual OS values; for this test backup exposure follows the backing image,
not the automatic mount flag. This choice does not change OS exclusions and does
not silently replace an earlier refusal with success. Production profiles retain
the strict default; null/unknown local policy refuses before custody effects.
A backup of the image is a copy of the keystore and lies outside crypto-erasure assurance, alongside copied keydirs or whole-host images. It can preserve keys removed from the active store. The explicit fixture adoption does not broaden that assurance or change source identity, signatures, retention deadlines, encryption, host FileVault, mount/instance binding, or missing-mount refusal. This local media choice is not a new public source-identity parameter: the signed profile already excludes copies of the keystore/image from its erasure guarantee. A new observed positive preflight under the named policy is required separately from the preserved strict negative case.
source/ref is HMAC-SHA256 under an independent binding key over a framed
participant/context/epoch tuple. Normal renewal keeps that key; reset creates a
new one. Old binding and all reset-linking ciphertext keys retire after signed
revocation publication/readback plus 300 seconds. The active replacement map
has no predecessor. Other identifying data retires 24 hours after the maximum
of epoch end, last certificate/request expiry and revocation publication ACK.
Duplicate requests never extend that deadline. Nonidentifying digest-to-digest
tombstones and aggregate counters can remain seven days. Each decision includes a fresh, uniformly random 256-bit
decision/nonce, covered by its signature and held only in the encrypted private
payload. The council must never retain that nonce in tombstones or logs. Without
it, the public certificate, known applicant/request digest and retained council
signing key could reconstruct a candidate decision and test its tombstone digest,
undoing erasure. A duplicate reuses the frozen nonce and exact ciphertext; it
never generates a new decision. The applicant keeps its own authorized copy.
The result link is limited to request digest → digest of the full signed,
nonce-bearing decision. A certificate digest, source/nym reference or digest
of a nonce-free decision projection is not an allowed replacement tombstone.
Request nonces also remain private. The issuer draws decision entropy
independently of public nonces, timestamps and key references.
Key use and key retention have different deadlines. Fixed request-recipient
keys retain their fixed expiry. A binding or transition awaiting a required
revocation publication must instead carry provider-local awaiting-publication
state, the exact committed scope/snapshot and its retention rule. An acknowledged
signed status plus matching readback fixes the first ACK time and resulting
destruction deadline; duplicate ACKs cannot replace it with a later time. This
never extends issuance beyond the context epoch. Pending-publication keys count
toward the same capacity ceiling and require bounded reconciliation and visible
operator attention. If ACK never arrives, this rule supplies no absolute calendar
destruction deadline; the implementation must expose that limitation, not invent
an infinite timestamp or silently use epoch-end plus retention. Publication-link
metadata is held with the erasable key, not in retained destruction receipts.
The optional issuer implements this lifecycle with provider fences and bounded
S020 reconciliation. It still needs real Gate A qualification.
Opaque private snapshots and factual publication readback (2026-10-26)¶
The stable context/epoch key fences the opaque journal. It must not encrypt identifying maps or expose stable participant lookup deltas next to public reset revocation deltas. Each full private current-state snapshot instead uses a fresh, independently random erasable snapshot key. The outer checkpoint contains only opaque key/chunk references, ciphertext, public signed status and nonidentifying nonce-bearing decision commitments/prepared encrypted replies. Identifying lookup maps remain inside that snapshot; the current map has no predecessor/reset link. This uses the existing bounded checkpoint, not an unbounded historical map cache.
A reset's publication ACK retires every prior private snapshot key that could recover the old map, the old binding key and all issuer-side request/bootstrap/ transition keys that retain the reset link, within the profile reset buffer. The current independent snapshot remains readable. Retaining the epoch fencing key or restoring an old DB/WAL must not recover those old maps. Obsolete key references may remain opaque for bounded reconciliation; permanent destruction receipts contain no participant, source or publication-link metadata. This protects controlled retained bytes, not outside timing inference or the council's prior knowledge. Pending keys count toward the same provider capacity ceiling.
Key creation enters awaiting-publication before a domain snapshot references it. The exact committed head is then attached by provider CAS before exposing an output. Finalization stops future use without inventing a destruction timestamp; normal minimum end-of-use remains the epoch boundary, while reset finalization uses the accepted shorter reset rule. A duplicate operation cannot choose new keys, deadlines or bytes after a crash.
Publication ACK is a durable historical fact, not a collection/emission lease. The owner selects the exact prepared signed status and committed head; its trusted publisher adapter reads that publication back. The verifier checks signature, canonical exact bytes, scope, minimum revision and required revocations, with an observed time no earlier than status issuance. Status expiry or epoch end does not invalidate factual readback completed later. It does not renew status freshness for admission or emission. The verified readback time and its exact signed status are committed under a provider-fenced Ready head before cleanup. Reopening that head must finish key acknowledgements locally even when the publisher is now offline; it cannot repeat network I/O as a prerequisite for the already acknowledged retirement. The frozen time cannot move forward on a restart. Equality/crypto conformance alone proves no backend I/O; real publication/readback remains a runtime Gate A obligation.
Destruction durably retires a key, fences and drains operations, removes the key file, fsyncs its directory and persists a receipt. Provider-local lifecycle metadata prevents old DB restore from undoing retirement. Startup finishes due destruction before decrypting private state. A missing key never invokes get-or-create or mints a replacement counting source.
Normal epoch closure is an explicit owner transition even when no later request arrives. It fences a complete opaque key-handle set, verifies factual readback, commits Closed state and acknowledges the current map/bindings before the epoch fence key. Closing does not mint a post-epoch key or renew eligibility. The outer journal never exposes a cumulative epoch-keyed nym-tag history: such tags belong inside erasable full snapshots, because their deltas can reveal a reset successor.
After the profile's finite replay-retention window, a bounded owner sweep removes
closed-scope request/result markers and ciphertext caches. A provider-local
metadata-only retirement revision fences the purge, so restoring an older database
cannot revive lookup results. It does not reactivate a key. A lookup with no retained
result means not-found-or-expired; it is never permission to reissue. Bootstrap
exchanges that never reached a context decision need the same bounded sweep using
their immutable verified epoch/deadline and expired recipient-key state.
The guarantee covers logical unreadability of controlled database, WAL and app backup copies. It does not cover raw SSD/APFS blocks, snapshots or images that copied the keydir, host images, or memory captured before destruction. The participants' own Vault/recovery material has its separate custody policy.
Exact encoding and signature preimages¶
All new P015 exchange plaintexts use UTF-8 JCS (JcsV1), without BOM or trailing
bytes. Require NFC for all names and string values before signing. Reject a
received private request unless its bytes equal its parsed JCS serialization;
this also rejects duplicate decoded object keys and ambiguous serializations.
This is a new-family rule; historical certificate and Agora bytes are untouched.
Every digest below is SHA-256, unpadded canonical base64url, prefixed sha256:.
The context preimage is exactly the JCS object with keys domain (constant
orbiplex.whisper.context.v1), federation/id, profile/digest, issuer/id,
topic/class, signal/similarity-key. The profile digest hashes the complete
profile's JCS. The binding MAC preimage is the JCS array
["orbiplex.whisper.source-binding.v1", participant, contextDigest, epoch].
source/ref is source: followed by canonical base64url of that MAC.
All new-profile Ed25519 verification is strict and refuses weak public keys, including new-nym proof of possession. This is an explicit profile rule, not a retroactive change to every historical v1 signature verifier.
Signing preimages use a literal ASCII domain followed by one NUL byte and JCS:
| Signature | Domain | Removed top-level fields |
|---|---|---|
| New nym proof of possession | orbiplex.nym-issuance-proof.v1 |
nym/proof, signature, bootstrap/proof |
| Participant request | orbiplex.nym-issuance-request.v1 |
signature, bootstrap/proof (includes the nym proof) |
| Full request bootstrap possession | orbiplex.nym-issuance-bootstrap-proof.v1 |
bootstrap/proof (includes both prior signatures) |
| Issuer decision | orbiplex.nym-issuance-decision.v1 |
signature |
| Source status | orbiplex.nym-source-status.v1 |
signature |
| Issuer exchange-key offer | orbiplex.nym-exchange-key-offer.v1 |
signature |
The certificate preserves v1: JCS of the certificate minus signature, no
prefix. Requiring NFC makes both existing certificate canonicalizers agree.
Verify the new nym PoP, then the participant signature, then the ephemeral
bootstrap proof before any issuance effect. The request digest hashes the
complete canonical signed request, including all three proofs. The private
request and decision bind exchange/handle; outer ciphertexts and AD artifact
IDs carry that handle, never the real signed-request digest. The private issued
decision carries its actual status/min-revision; the public certificate's
constant floor cannot substitute for it. Decision recipient and issuer must
equal the request's exact bindings. The certified nym/profile/context,
epoch and route must equal that request. A fresh nym may not reuse the applicant's
primary public key. A certificate must carry mandatory compatible Agora scope
restrictions: exact topic key, federation, record kind whisper-signal, content
schema whisper-signal.v2, and its supported disclosure scopes. The contextual
profile cannot be accepted through the generic verifier as an unrestricted nym.
D supplies a signed nym-exchange-key-offer.v1 for the anonymous first leg:
exact handle, ephemeral bootstrap public key, signed reply public key, digest
of that first-leg request, recipient X25519 key/ref and expiry. Preparing an
offer does not decide issuance. It does not contain the participant, actual
nym, context or real signed-request digest. The offer is outside the full
request's signed bytes, avoiding a digest cycle. Its private verifier pins the
actual full request in memory before sealing it. Key ref hashes the 32 raw
public-key bytes. No unbound reply address or key is accepted.
A freezes one random handle and operation nonce before minting. Inside the
Vault, a separate HKDF domain and that nonce derive an ephemeral Ed25519
bootstrap key E from protected nym material. E differs from the primary and
actual nym public keys. The narrow nym-exchange-key-request.v1 contains only
handle, approved profile/issuer, E public key, reply X25519 public key and validity;
it is signed by E. It carries no applicant, actual nym, context, predecessor,
certificate, reply participant or real signed-request digest. Its preimage is
orbiplex.nym-exchange-key-request.v1 + NUL + JCS minus signature.
The full private request includes the same handle, E key and reply key, with
the third E proof binding the already participant/nym-signed candidate.
A uses an independently adopted nym-bootstrap-recipient.v1, signed by the
profile's council, binding its separate X25519 bootstrap key/ref, exact profile,
peer node, purpose and validity (at most 24 hours). Its signature preimage is
orbiplex.nym-bootstrap-recipient.v1 + NUL + JCS minus signature. Council
signature verifies the descriptor, but grants no AD/INAC authority. Root-admitted,
exact peer/family/artifact request and reply invitations remain mandatory.
D opens only anonymous first-leg metadata with the global bootstrap-purpose key. It verifies E possession and validity before preparing one per-handle recipient key. The real participant and nym proofs are checked only after opening the full private request under that recipient. Exact encrypted-input identities, handle and finite deadline are reserved before effects. Random per-purpose allocation identifiers remain inside a separate erasable sealed payload; retained provider operation bindings do not carry the real request digest. A restored database missing frozen output refuses reconciliation rather than encrypting a replacement under the same artifact ID.
The independent provider response fence binds handle, closed phase, exact input-ciphertext digest, output-ciphertext digest and immutable replay deadline. KeyOffer and Decision have distinct slots; an internal sealed allocation slot is not a new wire phase or delivery queue. A preexisting reservation may finish its frozen output commitment after recipient-key destruction, without new key use. Global SQL ciphertext rows are retained replay source, not disposable context projections. Their lookup needs no surviving private map or scan of context membership. Private maps hold real request-digest/reply membership and quota; outer checkpoints do not expose those joins. Expired provider markers retain only opaque identity/deadline and cannot reopen an old exchange.
Domain clocks use the provider's durable high-water, not an application-DB- restorable clock floor. A changed ciphertext under the same handle/phase conflicts; duplicates reuse exact frozen bytes. Bootstrap metadata still exposes peer activity to its authorized receivers, but not a participant-to-nym/context mapping. The global bootstrap key cannot open full requests, offers or decisions. A fresh operator-approved Decision reply invitation can retrieve an already prepared historical result within its finite retention horizon after request expiry. It cannot authorize a new expired issuance or extend key/record validity. KeyOffer consent retains the original request deadline.
The earlier unqualified candidate used the signed-request digest as the transport identifier and a primary-signed metadata first leg. This decision was superseded on 2026-10-26 after the exact reset-link counterexample; its source-specific findings remain in Node's certification component audit. Neither candidate is promoted to Gate A by schema or software conformance alone.
Each encrypted payload has its own outer AD family: nym-key-request-sealed.v1,
nym-key-offer-sealed.v1, nym-issuance-request-sealed.v1, and
nym-issuance-decision-sealed.v1. The common nym-exchange-sealed.v1 schema
checks their closed outer/inner pairing; it is not a grant for every direction.
Before AD submission, each phase durably freezes its exact canonical sealed
envelope, including ephemeral public key, nonce and ciphertext. Retransmission
reuses those bytes; it never re-encrypts even identical plaintext under the same
artifact/idempotency id. AD alone owns transport retries.
An invitation names one exact family and deterministic artifact id derived from
the random exchange handle H and exact phase/family (direction alone collides
between bootstrap and issuance). Both artifact id and AD idempotency key are
exactly urn:orbiplex:nym-exchange:<outer-family>:<unprefixed-exchange-handle>.
No signed-request digest appears in that public transport identity.
Malformed family pairing never tries another key
purpose, decryptor or admission policy. This refines an unqualified, prerelease
codec; it makes no claim about deployed-state compatibility.
For nym-exchange-sealed.v1, the header is the complete envelope minus
ciphertext. All base64url strings are canonical, unpadded. The ephemeral sender
key and 24-byte nonce are random and never reused. HKDF-SHA256 uses the existing
X25519 primitive, UTF-8 exchange/handle as salt, and the bytes
orbiplex.nym-exchange-sealed.v1 + NUL + header JCS as info. Reject the all-zero
shared secret. XChaCha20-Poly1305 uses that derived 32-byte key, header JCS as AAD,
and the exact canonical plaintext. Decryption checks expected exchange, payload
family and recipient key before exposing plaintext; maximum plaintext is 64 KiB.
The sender's ephemeral private key is not persisted. Provider leases fence the
recipient key throughout decryption. A replayed ciphertext cannot revive a
retired exchange or bypass request idempotency.
Trade-offs and failure modes¶
A named publication-time authority improves late delivery but adds explicit trust in that authority's clock. Unknown evidence, missing issuer status, unavailable keys or a failed policy check cannot silently select another profile. Transient failures defer. Permanent refusals carry typed field/reason diagnostics. A one-hour collection lease trades revocation reaction latency for availability; first emission still requires a five-minute status. A lone council remains an availability and metadata-concentration limitation of Phase 1.
Open questions¶
No policy question blocks the accepted profile. The bounded adapter, capacity, lifecycle and evidence-size gates have measured scope in the closeout above; new workloads/profiles still require their own measurements.
Acceptance contract¶
- Freeze schema/DTO parity, negative fixtures and shared JCS golden vectors.
- Qualify Gate A: issue, lazy renew, reject, private reset, readback, duplicates, lost replies, restart, wrong authority/recipient/digest/PoP, status rollback, equivocation, cryptographic destruction/crash/DB restore and mount refusals.
- Qualify Gate B on SQLite and pinned unmodified Synapse: real UI/host nym signing, confidence 0.5, two participant sources, one threshold/proposal, same participant across nodes/nyms, expiry/revocation/reset, late first receipt after certificate expiry but before epoch end, restart and replay.
- Scan public records, full PDUs, UI/API/SSE/notifications, logs and durable AD copies under their declared access class for identity/key canaries. Private authorized recipient payloads are distinct from public leakage surfaces.
- Remove the environment acceptance signer before final Gate B. Use four roles A/B (ordinary applicants), C (sole projection authority) and D (council plus separate bootstrap authority). A read-only observer never publishes.
- Retain both gates in campaign P015-003/profile whisper-contextual-authorship, with <=16 MiB combined positives, XZ 128 MiB, <=1/4 MiB refusal budgets and <=64 KiB new Git metadata. Preserve equal loose/extracted/two-store results. The fixture's 10-minute epoch and 2-minute certificate prove mechanics; controlled-clock conformance proves production seven-day/24-hour bounds.
Local issuer state recovery¶
The issuer's temporal store appends encrypted transaction/event facts and derives its current context projection, following S028. Each exact profile, issuer, context and epoch has an independent lookup key and provider-local revision commitment. State revisions are local recovery counters, distinct from signed source-status revisions. A checkpoint contains public facts and opaque keyed lookups/handles/ciphertexts only. Independently erasable binding and transition keys protect identifying payloads; an epoch-wide key cannot preserve a private reset's predecessor link.
Commit the exact event, opaque payload and projection in SQL, then CAS the provider's previous revision/digest to the new revision/digest before exposing output. Interrupted recovery may finish that exact saved successor. A database behind the provider refuses; it cannot regenerate decisions or resurrect sources. Rebuilding a projection replays immutable ciphertext facts without re-signing, opening erased payloads or applying today's issuance policy. No provider, media, signing or network work runs inside the SQL write transaction. The reference implementation bounds an opaque context checkpoint at 32 MiB and its local event history at 65,536 entries; each key seal/open keeps its own 64 KiB budget. These are local capacity refusals, not an increase in public status or artifact limits. This foundation alone does not qualify either runtime gate.
Narrow bootstrap delegation and local consent¶
The root-admitted capability-issuance authority approves separate, beneficiary- bound nym-only delegations for ordinary A/B and D's receiver. The existing V2 beneficiary equality is unchanged: a delegate issues only for its own participant and Node. D cannot issue consent on behalf of A/B. Council certification, root transport authority and local recipient consent remain independent.
nym-bootstrap-consent is a singleton issuance template; it cannot share a grant
with Messaging templates. Its host-resolved caller is host:nym-bootstrap.accept.
It can issue only an inac-invitation@v1 child, single-use, for exactly one peer,
one P015 sealed family, one phase-qualified artifact ID, application/json, and
a TTL no greater than 900 seconds or the parent's remaining validity. The exact
INAC offer key (including the ciphertext digest) remains the consent reference.
The four families are nym-key-request-sealed.v1, nym-key-offer-sealed.v1,
nym-issuance-request-sealed.v1 and nym-issuance-decision-sealed.v1.
The P084 origin-v3 exchange requires a separate, explicit
nym-bootstrap-consent-v2 singleton template (accepted extension, 2026-11-06).
Its four families are the same key request/offer v1 plus
nym-issuance-request-sealed.v2 and nym-issuance-decision-sealed.v2.
Both templates retain the same beneficiary equality, host caller, exact peer,
phase-qualified artifact/digest consent, single use and 900-second parent-bound
TTL. Neither template admits the other's request/decision version. The original
template keeps its four-family meaning; an existing signed grant does not gain
v2 authority. The host selects a revision explicitly from its adopted exchange,
and a root must separately approve that template. Nym grants of either revision
cannot mix with Messaging templates or make Messaging readiness ready. Transport
delegation is independent of council certification, profile admission and the
publication window. Runtime qualification of this extension remains open.
An active parent delegation is not local consent. A/B's host must bind incoming replies to a durable, approved local exchange intent, expected D peer, phase and digest. D's host uses its separately installed issuer-receive policy to approve the exact offered peer/phase/artifact; certificate admission is decided later. A module cannot assert the host caller or impersonate an explicit operator. Until these host adapters are implemented, the pure template alone cannot cause an invitation. No sovereign fallback exists on the nym path. Grant status retains its existing 300-second budget, independent of nym source-status freshness. Nym-only grants do not make Messaging issuance/readiness ready and cannot issue Messaging send or receive passports. This is the narrow P015 exception to P076's original Messaging-only decision, not an expansion of its historical evidence.
Qualification blockers found during implementation review (2026-10-26)¶
The reviewed private exchange draft required another correction before Gate A. A still-live global bootstrap recipient can open historical first-leg metadata; that metadata must not contain the participant, actual nym, context or real signed-request digest. Use an independently random exchange handle and an unlinked ephemeral proof key for that anonymous first leg. The full request still carries the participant signature and actual nym proof inside its per-exchange encrypted recipient.
Durable global replay binds the opaque handle and phase to the exact sealed input digest, exact sealed output, artifact identity and finite deadline. It must not retain a request-to-context/status/checkpoint join. Identifying reply membership, decision material and quota belong in independently erasable private snapshots; a phase-qualified provider fence preserves the same replay bytes without reopening an erased map. Domain idempotency still uses the real signed-request digest inside that private boundary. No pool of random handles or transport receipt grants council authority.
A positive software attack probe reproduced the old bootstrap/checkpoint join. The reviewed baseline also generated a public status revision for every request, which exposed a reset through the new certificate's unique minimum revision. Neither software conformance nor a passing workspace gate qualifies these privacy properties. Gate A remains pending until both counterexamples fail on the corrected design and the real private runtime is qualified. Gate B remains pending independently. Timing analysis, the issuer's contemporaneous knowledge and copies of its still-live keystore/image remain outside the erasure claim.
Reference-owner status capacity and lifecycle¶
Status freshness requires schedulable work, not only a bounded number of rows. The reference owner refreshes by due time before its ordinary maintenance rotation and yields new issuance to runnable overdue status work. Its local configuration capacity is derived from the profile freshness age, cadence, cooperative work-slot budget and a reserved in-flight slot. Unsupported capacity refuses before key-provider initialization. No new lease follows from a queue, a retry or a budget overrun. These execution limits are not protocol namespace limits; larger capacity needs separate throughput qualification.
A public lease refresh must not require re-encrypting an unchanged private participant map or allocating new identifying-custody keys. It retains its own recoverable publication/readback boundary and the last private-effects fence. Reset eligibility drains the latest signed collection lease even if the private map's cached lease predates that refresh. Key retirement, source rollback protection and exact prepared decision replay remain unchanged. Local readers must explicitly distinguish checkpoint semantics; no old reader may silently use the cached private timestamp as the latest public lease.
The current-status consumer may checkpoint a verified cumulative signed head and its exact high-water cursor, then atomically remove superseded cache facts and bytes. Historical admission evidence is owned separately and is not pruned by this cache lifecycle. A monotone per-profile retired-epoch floor frees ended scope watches while refusing their reactivation after restart, rebuild or clock rollback. The latest cumulative revocations and live-scope HWM are preserved; retired floors cannot be reset to regain capacity. Local cache capacity is a simultaneous-use limit, not a lifetime limit on valid status revisions or epochs.
Uncommitted key allocation recovery¶
Publication-bound key records are also the durable inventory of unfinished preparations. The single issuer writer must reconcile the complete committed source with the provider high-water mark before destroying an allocation without a publication boundary. A missing projection or an SQL error alone is not proof that the candidate failed to commit. A committed candidate finishes its existing fences and exact prepared output; an unused candidate is retired with a durable no-recreation marker. Ambiguous, corrupt or restored old source refuses cleanup. An unused epoch root survives until epoch end and is destroyed only after its verified empty scope has no remaining candidate allocations. Startup and bounded S020 maintenance resume this reconciliation without a publication ACK for a candidate that was never published. No new permanent request-to-source join is introduced for cleanup.
Current implementation checkpoint (2026-10-28)¶
The dated 2026-10-26 counterexamples above remain historical review findings. The Node foundation now has software regressions for anonymous first-leg metadata, independent erasable reply membership, and the post-reset collection lease drain. They are not substitutes for the complete runtime privacy gate.
A clean-source private diagnostic has exercised issue, renewal with a new nym and the same contextual source, ordinary protected host signing, and exact certificate/authoring readback after applicant and issuer restart. The following private reset expired during processing and remains an original refusal. No request window was extended and no complete Gate A/B result is claimed.
The implementation now authenticates a sealed request and binds its custody from
one immutable allocation, removing repeated metadata decryption and provider
inspection. Controlled-media conformance measures 16 versus 8 attestations for
that input path. Actual key leases, media checks and request/signing/commit
expiry rules remain intact; the measurement does not promise a latency bound.
A new clean-candidate reset probe and the full two-gate qualification are still
required. See node:nym-issuer-service/README.md and the Node implementation
ledger for repository-local implementation status.
The 2026-10-28 status/ownership review is implemented at Node d69a5fec:
118 issuer and 58 host tests pass, including pre/post-commit allocation recovery,
deadline priority/backpressure, cumulative-checkpoint rollback, atomic cleanup
refusal, and capacity reuse after a full 1024-watch epoch. Strict all-target
Clippy and documentation checks pass. At that source revision, full/light
workspace gates refused on the independently owned Sensorium evidence-history
budget. This is software
conformance, not the runtime qualification of either Gate A or Gate B; the
P015-001–003 tracker and the aggregate authorship slice remain incomplete.
Consumer: author disclosure conditions (2026-10-27)¶
P013 author disclosure conditions
count this profile's sources without changing the profile. They evaluate one
epoch at a time and never sum epochs. In the protected signal's epoch they
exclude the author's source/ref exactly; in later epochs they require one
additional source, because the author cannot be recognized there. They use the
same status freshness, revocation and publication-time rules as first emission.
Implement these consumers over one revision-bound contribution evaluator, with
separate coordination participation/latch and disclosure-consent decisions;
P013's implementation recommendations
own its count/evidence shape and replay fixtures. The existing M4 node-counting
path is not a contextual-source implementation and keeps its historical ids.
Privately carried v2 signals reach the counting authority without a relay, so
their publication-time evidence must come from that authority's durable
admission receipt. Gate B qualifies Agora carriage only; the private carriage
belongs to P013-ADC-004.
Consumer: long-lived rumors (2026-10-27)¶
P013 long-lived rumors
keep certificates short. The SQLite admission receipt used above as
publication-time evidence becomes an instance of the portable
agora-publication-receipt.v1,
so other nodes can verify later that a record was admitted while its nym proof
was valid. That historical validity grants no current authority and does not
extend this profile's epoch or counting rules.
Case-bound succession adds no public succession to this profile. Routine
renewal still keeps the source without any succession artifact, and a private
reset still publishes no successor. A participant who wants a later nym to
continue one case uses
nym-succession.v2
with scope case, authorized by a continuity key committed in the case's first
signal and delivered privately to a named audience
(P013-LLR-007).
The predecessor nym key is not kept for that purpose.
Resumed qualification and refresh scheduling (2026-10-28)¶
The resumed Node b7f184be diagnostic observed an issued certificate through
ordinary private AD and a protected host signature with confidence 0.5. Its
renewal expired after repeated nym-issuer-status-maintenance-due decisions;
the original refusal is retained and does not qualify Gate A or Gate B.
The implementation separates two local execution deadlines. Early status refresh is scheduled at 10% of the emission freshness age. Issuance backpressure reserves one provider work slot before the earlier of actual emission freshness and signed status expiry. A successful provider call may outlast the early scheduling age; that alone must not eliminate every issuance window. A failed refresh's backoff cannot extend the admission boundary. These scheduling rules neither alter the profile digest and validity limits nor turn a stale status into emission authority. Full certification lifecycle and contextual relay/aggregate qualification remain required before closing the two gates.
The subsequent clean 4777ccd5 private repeat reached renewal's full-request
invitation but retained consent-busy refusal. Prepared ciphertext/readback lookup
now uses the existing immutable output/provider/expiry checks without taking the
runtime mutation fence. Channel-gated concurrency conformance and all 123 issuer
cases pass. Neither this owner repair nor either private probe qualifies the
complete lifecycle or contextual relay/aggregate runtime.
The clean bd825b2e cycle completed ordinary issue and renewal, with a new nym,
the same source and exact signed readback. Reset retained expiry after repeated
AD retry collisions with maintenance. A bounded, transient ingress hint now
allows a turn between work slots while preserving hard freshness backpressure,
ordinary maintenance attempts and the original signed request deadline. The hint
is neither an admission fact nor a new transport queue. Conformance passes 126
issuer and seven issuer-host cases; actual complete lifecycle and Gate B remain
unqualified.
Shared consumer boundary (2026-10-29)¶
Node's whisper-core now owns a pure, revision-bound source-contribution
evaluator for coordination and later disclosure consumers. It counts distinct
admitted sources in one complete exact epoch inventory, retains all eligible
records, filters revocations before representative choice and commits the private
evidence basis. It does not create admission facts, nonce reservations, authority,
consent or a first-emission latch. Incomplete inventory and stale status remain
unavailable. The historical node-counting M4 qualification is unchanged.
Seventy-five component conformance cases and strict all-target Clippy pass.
Private a77105e2 diagnostics observed ordinary AD issue, renewal and reset;
a separate lazy renewal after reset activation preserved exact certificate and
signed-record readbacks across A/D restart. An original pre-reset ciphertext
probe returned key-destroyed after pre-existing provider destruction. Those
observations and the retained original harness refusals are not complete Gate A/B
qualification. Both gates remain pending in the tracker and Node ledger.
Authenticated scope refresh during issuance (2026-10-29)¶
The issuer's local scheduler must distinguish an anonymous reservation from a full authenticated request that will publish a fresh status for its own exact scope. That full decision can perform its own refresh under the same mutation fence and mandatory publication/readback. Waiting first for a separate refresh of that same scope can otherwise consume every retry until a valid request expires. Other due contexts retain their reservation; an anonymous request cannot choose or infer the excluded scope.
The fb133aa9 diagnostic's immutable AD attempt history records six such
maintenance-due results followed by original expiry. The repair changes no
profile identity, signed deadline, reset activation drain, status lease or
independent council policy. An end-of-epoch renewal that cannot extend validity
still receives a signed refusal. This is an owner execution correction, with
both full runtime gates still pending after it.
Local atomic-admission foundation (2026-10-29)¶
The Node SQLite owner now composes pending contextual verification with its existing relay ingest. The exact author buffer, signed relay-clock receipt, nonce/record reservation, admission facts and selected cumulative status checkpoint commit together. Signature verification precedes SQL; checkpoint CAS, collection freshness and epoch closure are checked at commit. Repeated delivery of the completed command preserves its original facts, and a generic historical record cannot acquire a retroactive admission/time claim.
This storage mechanism implements the earlier atomicity decision; it does not create issuer trust, authorize publication, replace backend clock policy or emit an aggregate. Contextual HTTP/Matrix wiring, the host/UI flow, current source projection and first-emission CAS remain implementation/qualification obligations. No tracker gate is closed by signed-fixture SQLite tests.
A clean d7595742 private repeat completed ordinary AD issue, lazy renewal,
private reset, refusal before activation, protected signing after activation and
exact certificate/request/document readback after A/D restart. This is a diagnostic
lifecycle, not the complete Gate A qualifier. The old-ciphertext probe also remains
a limited refusal check: routine snapshot replacement can retire its key, so that
probe alone does not establish reset-caused erasure. Gate A and Gate B remain
pending, with original failed attempts preserved and no readiness promotion.
A successful local contextual mutation now retains a nanosecond clock high-water
checkpoint alongside its status/admission transaction. Reopening cannot accept a
cryptographically valid decision earlier than this owner already observed.
Missing clock state beside contextual history is an explicit refusal, not a new
initialization. Readback and exact completed-command retry keep original facts.
This local restart fence does not claim protection against restoring an entire
older database. The clean Node c09fa017 / Orbidocs 8e12cae7 full software gate
passed 9,097 tests with zero failures and 127 explicit ignores; that baseline
precedes the separately tested clock correction and does not qualify A or B.
Source/checkpoint composition and actual private diagnostics (2026-10-29)¶
The SQLite owner now accepts the same opaque contextual preparation beside a Matrix source decision. Exact author bytes, independently admitted clock source, event binding and first local receipt are checked before the transaction; nonce, status CAS, admission, source, retained time and account/job progress commit together. Multiple carriers preserve one first locally admitted fact. An existing rejected event cannot be upgraded or leave an orphan reservation. The pure Matrix codec/client and wire carrier remain independent of this optional owner policy. Signed fixture tests cover source/checkpoint and history-job rollback, restart, status races, duplicate observations and clock/source substitution. They do not qualify Synapse or the contextual service/UI/projection path.
The d7595742 runtime also observed ordinary issue53/renewal54/reset55 and a
separate signed council refusal over still-admitted AD transport. A sequential
provider probe verified the same live binding MAC before reset and
key-destroyed after the actual reset and retirement buffer; no key or private map
was exported. Its initial concurrent-provider startup refusal remains preserved.
A/D restart preserved the exact certificate, request reference, preview and signed
record without a new signing/issuance command. These remain scoped private
diagnostics pending complete independent case qualification and retention.
No A/B gate, aggregate, disclosure or global readiness status is promoted.
The later probe review removes automatic recovery-bundle downloads. A missing current recovery bundle stops the canonical runner after stable preparation; the operator completes protected recovery/export separately, outside retained evidence/cache, before resuming the same operation/deadline. Older diagnostic runs that downloaded/discarded the response do not establish recoverable custody. The public v2 signal boundary now reuses the existing nym/proof/kind and public disclosure/routing checks; direct routing cannot silently pass as unknown v2 content. This preserves the adopted carrier policy without qualifying contextual counting, UI, aggregate emission or either full runtime gate.
The later receiver composition carries the same opaque contextual preparation through decoding to the existing source/checkpoint transaction. A deferred event preserves its original local receipt while admission evaluates the new status and epoch clock. Exact signed fixtures cover reopen, event-token substitution and rollback. Service policy wiring, UI and actual SQLite/Synapse qualification remain separate pending Gate B obligations; this port does not change the adopted publication-time authority or promote either gate.
Host-owned source-status acquisition¶
identity.nym.source-status.acquire accepts the closed
nym-source-status-acquire.local.v1: an already adopted profile digest, a
council-signed contextual certificate and explicit collection or
first-emission purpose. The certificate determines context/epoch. The caller
cannot supply a clock, endpoint, issuer adoption, private minimum revision or
signing authority. Invalid certificates and unknown profiles acquire no watch.
The optional host cache registers that verified live scope idempotently for its
existing bounded S020 refresh job. The request performs no network fetch or Vault
operation. nym-source-status-result.local.v1 distinguishes an available signed
snapshot from pending/unavailable or stale refresh. Available means status bytes
for that purpose, not certificate eligibility, record admission or permission to
emit. In particular, a revoked certificate can obtain the signed status that
proves its revocation. Callers recheck signatures, scope and time at use.
The authenticated current-operator route and explicitly adopted authenticated
receiver module bindings use the same owner. The receiver role is an exact local
operator selection, independent of package names and signing domains. Node's
startup identity.nym_status_consumer_modules policy defaults to the existing
agora-service binding; an explicit list replaces it, including an empty disabled
selection. It admits at most 16 distinct canonical module IDs. Null, duplicate,
malformed and reserved local-control selectors refuse; matching never normalizes
or expands aliases. Selection creates neither a credential nor an instance.
Independent receivers additionally present their current signed launch and exact
live channel identity. A registry entry or another module credential grants no
access. Acquisition does not require a certificate to be
unexpired now: the receiving owner separately verifies its trusted publication
time. Ended epochs do not gain a new watch or lease. Existing cumulative status
high-water marks and retirement remain authoritative. Missing refresh or storage
is deferred unavailability, never permission to fall back to the old P081 nonce
cache or to author-provided status/time. Implementation and qualification remain
separate from this contract.
The reference receiving service adopts profiles independently of the host cache. Its Matrix observation is bound to the authenticated client/account and configured clock authority. V2 admission has no fallback to the legacy current-certificate nonce cache. A distinct transport carrier of an already locally admitted record preserves its first admission and nonce decision; new carrier bytes/provenance remain separate. This historical read path cannot create missing domain facts or renew their time/status. Missing original record/author material is corruption, not a new admission opportunity. Software composition does not qualify Gate B.
Ordinary SQLite publisher composition (2026-10-29)¶
The reference local publisher independently adopts a relay clock and a named protected host proxy. That adoption does not grant the module a signing domain, unlock a key or derive trust from a certificate. Existing publisher ACL, content, disclosure, namespace and size checks remain in front of contextual admission. The host signs only the receipt's exact author-buffer-bound preimage outside SQL.
A newly prepared local receipt is not yet publication. Its record, exact author bytes, admission facts, nonce and receipt must commit together within the adopted profile's clock-skew window, checked after acquiring the writer. A separately durable receipt received late has a different path and preserves its original publication time. Neither path substitutes authored time or creates a missing historical fact. Exact completed-command readback uses the first receipt and repairs its derived index, without a new status acquisition or signature; a valid alternate JSON spelling remains an alternate buffer. Concurrent identical calls cannot replace the winning receipt with their later private preparations.
This service composition does not emit the contextual threshold. UI, Matrix publisher composition, current-source projection and full Gates A/B remain open. The actual clean candidate19 diagnostic issued and renewed through ordinary AD and protected host authorship. Its reset attempt retained an invitation-observation refusal, and an earlier recovery download exceeded the observation tool's bound. Encrypted authority recovery is retained separately from evidence; no old request deadline, formal acceptance claim or global readiness status is changed.
Selected ordinary SQLite observations (2026-10-29)¶
Node's reviewed 2084117d owner candidate, with the separately pinned ordinary
6efe21bd Agora service, completed independent A/B certification through private
AD, host/Vault signatures at confidence 0.5 and two C SQLite HTTP 201 publications
under one exact profile/context/epoch. C restart/readback preserved the original
author buffers, signed clock receipts and admission facts after certificate expiry.
Receipt signatures and both retained host documents passed separate checks.
A recoverable prepared-status startup refusal was reproduced and repaired without publishing at open or treating a private candidate as available status. A missing B fixture transport/allowlist retained its real refusal before explicit narrow preparation; no transport grant was treated as AD or council authority.
These selected observations do not close P015-001–003 or Gate B. Complete private lifecycle/failure qualification, certification UI, live contextual counting and first-emission orchestration, actual Synapse/PDU, replay and both-store retention remain required. See Node's resumption review for source-specific outcomes and preserved refusals. Historical node-counting M4, global Agora and release readiness retain their prior scope.
Complete local inventory component (2026-10-29)¶
The optional Node SQLite source owner now reads a complete adopted profile/context/epoch in bounded pages. Its private cursor and completion seal remain tied to the exact open owner. Per-scope source transaction revisions fence concurrent admission, status and retained dependency changes; another scope does not invalidate the read. A missing signed checkpoint is unknown, not zero, and a missing empty-scope head cannot reset its retained rollback history. Initial control installation is atomic and later missing controls refuse.
These are component completeness/concurrency facts. The seal does not grant admission, first-emission freshness or publication authority. The aggregate owner still must compose current source evaluation and revalidate the pin inside its actual durable mutation, with its clock and status policy. Component tests do not close Gate A/B, P015-001–003 or historical M4. See the Node source-owner README and resumption review for the bounded software scope.
Source-owned first-emission draft component (2026-10-29)¶
The optional Node source owner now composes the complete local inventory with the shared contextual-source evaluator. Typed retained facts are read after verifying their byte/hash/record binding; arbitrary decoded facts do not acquire live admission rights. The private preparation cannot accept a caller count or substitute a different profile/context/epoch basis.
The first mutation repeats source/status CAS in the source transaction, samples its clock and requires first-emission freshness. It freezes the selected signer and both exact v2 drafts once. The proposal binds the threshold content address before signing. Subsequent revocation changes the current count without replacing the historical pair, and the frozen basis retains its signed status. Partial control loss refuses rather than silently rearming first emission.
This is a bounded component implementation, not actual emission or Gate A/B qualification. Host signing/publication scheduling, certification UI, complete private failure coverage, Synapse/PDU, replay and both-store retention remain required. Historical M4 and global readiness retain their existing scope.
The Node owner also retains the first verified host-signed buffers before publication I/O and acknowledges only an actual durable local relay record. Threshold submission precedes proposal submission. Local acknowledgement is not Matrix forwarding or remote admission. Indexed selection is a bounded scheduling hint, not an eligibility/completeness proof; cooperative interruption creates no new emission fact. Unreleased local installation changes refuse unknown or old developer controls rather than silently rearming a latch. These component laws do not qualify the service scheduler, certification UI or either runtime gate.
The opt-in Node service composition now consumes the existing S020 module-job contract. Explicit local adoption selects one profile, authority, output topic and host key reference; incoming source fields cannot grant that authority. The job shares the collection/first-emission status verifier and the source owner's transaction fence, then uses ordinary protected host signing. Retained signed buffers precede local submission; Matrix forwarding remains the existing journal worker's responsibility. The module starts no private scheduler and installs no default job. Component conformance does not establish actual certification UI, source-result annotation or SQLite/Synapse qualification.
Current source annotation contract (2026-10-30)¶
whisper-contextual-source-view.local.v1 separates the current source count from
its last complete evaluation and the immutable first-emission references.
eligible and below-threshold require an unchanged complete source/status
revision and the emission freshness lease. Otherwise the current count is null
with freshness-unknown; the last evaluation remains explicitly historical.
At epoch closure the current count is zero and the state is epoch-ended.
A sampled clock earlier than the owner's committed high-water cannot produce
a fresh annotation. Reads neither advance that fence nor extend a status lease. A newer signed status or
source change invalidates the previous current count until reevaluation.
The read model is rebuildable. Deleting it must not erase or recreate the source-owned first-emission latch. A collection-only update may persist an annotation without authorizing a new pair. Its display is separate from the signed proposal and cannot rewrite the historical claim or trigger publication. A record-bound read retains that record's existing topic ACL and independently adopted local projection authority; imported claims cannot borrow a local basis.
Node now implements this read model over a rebuildable cache in the complete source owner's transaction. The record-bound API and UI preserve the topic ACL and exact frozen local claim binding. Refreshing a frozen pair does not frame or publish another pair. Component conformance covers revocation/restoration, freshness, corruption, rollback against the committed fence and cache rebuild. This does not close the complete certification UI, durable result-change audit, actual Gate A/B campaigns or retained proof obligations.
Explicit local certification controls (2026-10-30)¶
The protected Node UI now projects the existing operator-local applicant API. Each POST selects one explicit transition: prepare issue/renew/private reset, prepare a key request, submit one prepared encrypted artifact through AD, inspect its delivery, bind an exact reply offer, accept its exact INAC notification, or read the retained result. No transition is inferred from delivery success or the latest notification. Authority adoption remains an independent host decision.
Preparation keeps its operation identity and protected nym through a lost response. A form-only JCS digest confirms the exact prepared intent. Changed scope, operation or predecessor fields refuse before another owner transition; readback does not confirm edited fields. This digest is not issuance authority. A changed intent requires a new operation. The separate recovery guard still applies; these controls never export recovery, approve a peer implicitly, replace a reviewed authorship document or retry a mutation on transport failure. A 401 may refresh local authentication only because it precedes owner dispatch. The returned operation, profile, issuer and reply bindings must match the command.
The two mounted aliases share the authenticated operator proof, P095 private-view catalogue, CSRF protection, private/no-store responses and passphrase omission. Delivery, council decision, certificate validity/activation, status freshness and relay admission stay distinct in UI and API. Component checks do not qualify the actual private exchange, browser flow, SQLite/Synapse path or either Gate A/B. The source-result audit and all retained runtime obligations remain open.
Stable local basis identity and measured positive prefixes (2026-10-30)¶
The pure source evaluator distinguishes eligible-membership identity from revision/time-bound evaluation evidence. The local membership preimage binds the exact profile, context, epoch and sorted eligible source/record/certificate / original-admission-proof tuples. Refreshing evaluation time or an otherwise unchanged signed status does not create a membership change. A changed eligible record or proof does, even when the distinct-source count is unchanged. The existing evidence commitment and public signed contracts retain their preimages.
A subsequent source-owned result-change journal must preserve the first complete evaluation and actual membership changes under the same source/status commit CAS. It must retain the evaluated evidence and original status, remain separate from the rebuildable latest-view cache, and never rearm first emission. Its installation boundary cannot claim to reconstruct unrecorded earlier evaluations. The pure identity primitive does not itself implement that journal.
The private Node continuation has now observed ordinary A/B AD certification, protected host signing and a SQLite first pair after certificate expiry/restart. A separate canonical Synapse case observed two admitted sources, one first pair, exact author bytes through independent sync/durable source/full PDU, four native signatures and an actual C restart. Its maximum selected full PDU was 9,245 B. These positive prefixes do not close P015-003 or Gates A/B: full lifecycle, erasure/refusal, the complete browser/refusal matrix, replay, complete privacy and both-store retention qualification remain open. The Node ledger and resumption review own source-specific observations. Historical transport qualifications remain unchanged.
Source-owned result history component (2026-10-30)¶
Node now persists the initial complete evaluation and eligible-membership changes in the source owner's transaction. It keeps the evaluated source/status revision, original signed status, times and evidence commitments separate from the latest cache and immutable first pair. Time/status refresh without membership change is not another result change. Read-derived unknown freshness or epoch closure does not fabricate a complete evaluation fact. Historical reads do not evaluate the history against today's clock or grant admission/emission authority.
The local journal uses bounded exact-scope/authority keyset pages and commit order, without implying chronological Matrix order. Current installation version 3 and its separate journal marker refuse partial loss; an intact v2 upgrade preserves the first pair and explicitly declares unknown prior evaluation coverage. Old writers must be stopped before upgrade, and an old v2 opener refuses v3. Cache rebuild never resets audit or emission ownership. Local integrity checks are not portable attestation or whole-database rollback protection.
This is reviewed component implementation. The earlier private SQLite/Synapse positive prefixes predate the journal. Actual journal/replay qualification and full Gates A/B remain open; no historical transport or global readiness status changes follow from this component step.
Cold-start lock classification review (2026-10-30)¶
A later private signed-instance cold-copy startup preserved eight accepted records
and two immutable first pairs while installing the source result journal with
prior-coverage-unknown. This is an upgrade diagnostic, not fresh membership-change
or replay qualification. The original source database and instance remain intact.
Actual ordinary private AD issuance and the protected authorship UI reached
certificate readback and a retained preview. After restart, signing without an
unlock secret exposed a generic503 caused by loss of the typed protected-Vault
lock condition. The root owner now preserves the existing KeyLocked class for
P015423 handling. Missing status, invalid credentials and corruption remain
separate failures; unlock cannot extend certificate or preview validity. Component
tests and this correction do not close the pending fresh UI/runtime verification
or Gates A/B.
Ordinary UI smoke and fixture-signer retirement (2026-10-30)¶
After the typed-lock correction, an actual private AD/UI probe completed issue,
certificate readback, retained review, daemon restart,423, explicit unlock and
host signing of the same document with confidence=0.5, followed by Matrix202
publication intent. Daemon842ef007 and separately pinned317a87a0 UI/service were
recorded independently. This is a positive narrow path, not receipt, erasure,
complete lifecycle/replay or both-store qualification.
The environment-selected deterministic nym signer is removed from current intake runtime after that smoke. The current legacy Story-005 renderer no longer installs its seed/source variables; v1 primary-participant host signing cannot stand in for the new contextual source profile. Frozen historical tools and evidence retain their exact bytes. Final Gate B still requires a clean candidate without that side path and the complete qualification/retention matrix.
Historical source inspection and delayed collection (2026-10-30)¶
The verification-only native adapter reuses ordinary source/admission, receipt, status and aggregation owners at recorded times. It checks complete selected-scope inventory and rederives both first-emission drafts from their original basis. It creates no clock, nonce, source, signer or renewed admission authority.
A focused real AD/host signal published through the Matrix Client-Server API
before both certificate and one-shot proof expiry is admitted by C 8.9 seconds
after certificate expiry, within its original epoch. Independent read-only
/sync, exact author bytes and the complete signed PDU bind that observation.
Full PDU verification remains acceptance-only under the adopted
authenticated-admitted-homeserver-v1 runtime policy. This focused case does not
qualify Node's publication path, a new scheduled aggregate lifecycle, homeserver
size enforcement or federation. The original observer failures and the valid
refusal of a different document published after its proof expiry remain distinct.
P015-001–003 and Gates A/B stay partial: the complete shared profile qualifier, remaining runtime/uniqueness/privacy matrix and qualified two-store retention are still outstanding. See the Node resumption review for exact source pins and measured scope. No historical M4 or global readiness claim is promoted.
Independently inspected ordinary UI paths (2026-11-02)¶
The subsequent Node continuation independently inspects ordinary private AD and
protected host UI authoring on both SQLite and Matrix. The corrected Matrix
receiver starts without a live subscriber; actual restart and carrier replay
preserve original admission, author bytes and first-emission facts. Exact author
bytes also match an independent read-only sync observer and full stock Synapse
PDU. These are narrow measured cases, not a renewal of all historical transport
claims. The complete software gate passes on Node 925f68a2 / Orbidocs e767bf32
with 9,259 passes, zero failures and 127 existing ignores. Subsequent fixture
context/expiry refusals remain refused; no signed deadline is extended.
P015-001–003 and both complete A/B gates remain partial. The outstanding authority/status/reset/erasure-crash/privacy matrix, final backend campaign and identical loose/extracted/fresh two-store qualification still govern closure. Node's current ledger and dated resumption audit own detailed source/capture pins and individual results. Development retention, original protected evidence and global Agora/Whisper/release scope remain unchanged.
Qualification checkpoint (2026-11-02)¶
The corrected runtime independently verifies ordinary AD issue, lazy renewal
after actual certificate expiry, and private reset on the same protected path.
Fresh signed statuses and the certificate confirm reset activation after the
latest pre-reset collection lease plus the unchanged skew. A concrete old
ciphertext sample from a pre-reset application DB receives KeyDestroyed without
copying the keystore. This does not cover the full crash/WAL/export matrix.
An original private controller bookkeeping refusal remains preserved; independent
reinspection repeats no issuance/reset command. The clean Node software gate
passes 9,264/0/127 on 7a75376f / docs 70b0c2a4. Neither software checks nor
these selected runtime predicates close Gate A/B. The then-pending duplicate/
lost-reply predicate is advanced by the following checkpoint; authority, status,
erasure/privacy and final backend/retention obligations remain pending.
The Node audit and implementation ledger carry the precise source/proof scope.
Controlled private response recovery (2026-11-02)¶
Clean capture e100b94d with frozen runtime bde3272f completes a real
80.94-second four-process-birth A/D case. The same full request is submitted
twice; an original private response attempt fails while A is stopped. D then
stops and both owners restart. The prepared ciphertext, delivery plan and
expiry, nym, request deadline and owner decision remain exact, and the original
consented AD response reaches A. Explicit protected recovery and cleanup pass.
A fresh read-only predicate independently verifies issue, reference readback,
duplicate-request/reply and lost-response/restart subsets against original
observations, ready bootstrap capabilities and the native certificate verifier.
The default predicate refuses the unchanged fault-injected-runtime class.
This is controlled offline delivery failure within original AD expiry, not a
claim of spontaneous ACK loss or late retransport. The capture now separately
waits for issuer admission and initial AD submission, using only readbacks
within the original request window. Original prefix refusals remain intact.
The harness has 137 strict conformance passes and a green light gate. Full
software checks retain their separately pinned earlier revisions. P015-001–003
and both full runtime gates remain partial: the remaining authority/status/
erasure/privacy matrix, final SQLite/Synapse campaign and equivalent fresh
qualification from both retained locations still govern closure. The Node
resumption audit and implementation ledger own detailed source/proof bindings.
Encrypted-provider process interruption subset (2026-11-02)¶
Node 7da785e9 / docs 206f0acc now has four controlled native process cuts
and independent read-only predicates for those exact crash obligations. Each
cut uses a fresh provider on the adopted encrypted fixture. Startup after the
durable fence must leave the destroyed receipt and no key entry before a
recovering key API runs; before the fence, explicit replay remains necessary.
Original ciphertext and operation recreation then refuse with KeyDestroyed.
The earlier open-plus-state observation is preserved and refuses this stronger
predicate. These are process interruptions, not power-loss qualification.
139 provider and 149 harness conformance cases plus scoped strict Clippy/light checks pass. The Node resumption audit owns report/binary bindings. Remaining authority/status/old-database/privacy matrices, final SQLite/Synapse Gate B and fresh equivalent two-store retention keep P015-001–003 and aggregate A/B partial.
Fresh software prerequisite and proof inventory (2026-11-02)¶
Clean Node 16675e10 / docs 5d668ed6 passes the full nonincremental software
gate: 9,267 passed, zero failed, 128 explicit ignores, strict workspace/all-target
Clippy and final paths. The pair remains clean and unchanged throughout.
A fresh independent composition verifies 14/66 obligations, using 13 native
inspections plus the four-cut predicate over exact original inputs.52 still
remain open; the old six-obligation inventory keeps its historical scope.
These are software prerequisites and verified subsets, not complete Gate A/B or final both-store qualification. Subsequent history-count proofs must independently derive later bases; stale-database restoration must be tested within the live epoch so expiry cannot supply a false explanation. The Node ledger and resumption audit carry exact source/log/remaining-matrix bindings. P015-001–003 stay partial.
Independent complete-inventory inspection review (2026-11-02)¶
The Node acceptance verifier now has an explicit complete local inventory-cut mode, separate from the historical timestamp-selected adapter. It rederives the last recorded count, membership and evidence commitment with the ordinary owner evaluator and original signed status/time. Earlier transitions require their own snapshots. First drafts are verified only when that complete inventory also matches their original evidence commitment and stricter emission freshness; a later reset cut instead reports that an earlier cut is required.
Original SQLite/Matrix/uniqueness snapshots and a repaired-hash count mutation
exercise this distinction. These are conformance checks, not a renewed backend
runtime campaign.151 harness/102 package cases and scoped Clippy pass. A separate
real same-live-epoch old-DB restore refuses issuer-state-rollback, with original
DB/provider/config preserved and current readback restored. The readback occurs
outside the certificate window and does not prove renewed signing usability.
The Node audit records exact identities and the preserved unsuccessful observer.
P015-001–003 and Gates A/B remain partial: the independently verified inventory is still14/66, with final authority/status/erasure/privacy/backend and equivalent both-store qualification required. No production wire/profile/admission semantic changes or readiness promotion follow from this inspector review.
A subsequent actual same-epoch control on frozen application bde3272f and clean
capture 0c435ea0 / docs e5def2aa completes ordinary issue/reset, native refusal
of the stopped old DB, exact config restoration, ordinary renewal and host
signing confidence0.5. Fresh read-only inspection performs six native checks of
original AD, certificates and the exact review/signature. It verifies usability
of the current new source after refusal, beyond the earlier late readback.
The Node audit records original identities. The formal composite old-DB predicate,
remaining matrices and final both-store A/B qualification still govern closure;
the independently composed inventory remains14/66 and P015 stays partial.
The subsequent profile-owned composite reader binds that original stopped
snapshot and distinct native refusal to the ordinary AD issue/reset/renewal
predicates and exact restored host review. It can establish only the controlled
A/old-database-restore obligation, with fault-injected origin. A clean-source
reinspection must produce its proof; stored success flags and archived procedures
are not authority. Remaining gate and final retention requirements are unchanged.
Fresh clean Node c0b8e690 / Orbidocs 806b86b9 composition makes19 native
checks over1725 original artifacts and verifies15/66 obligations, including only
the newly added controlled old-database restore.51 remain missing.161 strict
Python cases and light/documentation gates pass; full A/B and both-store
qualification remain open. The Node audit binds the original result digest.
Stay-ready implementation checkpoint: Node now has pure consent/planning values with bounded slots, immutable CAS transitions, fixed operation/time, exact representable75–95% bounds and preserved source activation across renewal. The next Node component checkpoint adds a separately sealed host consent source and protected approval/readback/CAS-revocation API. It derives the scope from an accepted owned certification; duplicate approval cannot replace revocation or replenish an allowance. P072 registers three literal operator-only host routes, without generic dispatch or passport authority. Their readback explicitly reports execution as not enabled. The subsequent source checkpoint stores the exact reserved operation, deadline and certificate and uses separate local high-water marks to refuse rollback of SQLite/WAL. It can complete only the original authenticated one-step SQL successor, without resealing or repeating a command. This guarantee assumes preserved current authority anchors; an old whole-host snapshot cannot substitute for them. The effect-fenced S020 consumer, explicit replacement, operator UI and real unlock/recovery continuation remain required before renewal-consent conformance can be granted. A/B remains 15/66; these component changes add no runtime acceptance.
Narrow runtime and predicate review — 2026-11-03¶
The corrected issuer dispatch, current receiver admission/native pins and
fresh-process readiness are exercised by ordinary SQLite and Matrix UI cases.
They preserve the reviewed document through restart/423/unlock and publish
confidence 0.5 with host-held nyms. Independent native checks cover the signed
SQLite receipt, the original two-source Matrix first basis after certificate
expiry, and five complete Node-created v10 PDUs (maximum 9,285 B). A separate
read-only /sync client observes exact author buffers. Runtime still trusts the
explicitly adopted authenticated homeserver clock; full PDU verification remains
an acceptance operation. This does not renew transport-wide or federation claims.
The emitting C/D operator continuation is distinct from the earlier UI starts. Read-only composition must bind its independently adopted capture driver, actual processes, exact successful S020 receipt, subsequent public records and original complete native source cut. Missing or substituted lineage refuses; it is not inferred from a later SQLite snapshot or serialized success flags. The first software attempt's temporary-path/ancestry refusals remain recorded; its assertions and shared-volume permissions are preserved for a corrected run.
P015-001–003 and both whole gates remain partial. The prior 15/66 composition
retains its original scope; later narrow observations and new component
predicates require their own clean composition. Remaining authority/status/
erasure/privacy/backend/replay matrices and equivalent two-store retention are
still required. See node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md.
The acceptance-only Matrix composition additionally requires an independently
adopted standalone read-only client, its original process and ordered /sync
observations, exact source author buffers and complete PDU/export rows for the
same explicitly selected complete source cut. Retained aggregate author buffers
are facts separate from their typed signatures; absent buffers remain absent.
Fresh native hash/signature/size verification does not change the runtime clock
policy or establish room authorization/federation. Representative subsets cannot
stand in for full campaign coverage. Both whole gates and retained qualification
remain partial until the remaining obligations are composed.
A projector continuation may use the explicit acceptance protocol
bounded-launches.v2: 1–16 ordinary S020 operator launches, each bound to its
own original HTTP payload and indexed typed receipt, followed by the final
public read. The original single-launch format keeps its exact one-step rule.
This accommodates bounded projector work phases without changing launch
permissions, treating a busy 409 as success, or inferring missing execution
facts from the source snapshot. A controlled fixture explicitly disables its
projector's periodic dispatch in configuration before publication, then uses
authorized run-once. Process-local pause is not claimed to survive scheduler
registration on restart. The fixture restores periodicity by explicit adoption
afterwards. Both whole authorship gates remain partial.
The controlled SQLite pair at clean Node 591ecf06 / Orbidocs cd17826c
now produces one original threshold/proposal pair after both accepted signal
certificates expire beyond skew. Six separately receipted ordinary S020 steps
complete bounded projector phases; fresh native inspection verifies the complete
first basis and both original signed receipts. Explicit fixture periodicity is
restored afterwards. This is a narrow backend result, not complete Gate B or a
change to the last combined15/66 coverage inventory. The separately pinned
Node 0c2e4894 / Orbidocs 2ddb7ef0 full software gate passes9,313/0/128 with
strict Clippy and paths; software prerequisites do not establish either runtime
gate. Qualification review adds pre-read logical-path refusals. Full A/B and
final both-store qualification remain partial; the Node resumption audit owns
the exact observations and failure scope.
A fresh clean Node f9ec2370 read-only composition now verifies22/66 obligations
through49 native inspections of original inputs. The22 include narrow SQLite and
Matrix first-pair/expiry, SQLite signed receipts and the independent observer/full
PDU cut;44 remain. This is an explicitly heterogeneous prefix inventory, not a
final single-candidate A/B campaign or both-store qualification. Subsequent
ordinary A/A2 UI and a separately receipted sole-source control complete with
restored fixture periodicity; their uniqueness predicate is still pending.
An acceptance-only registration adapter separately adopts the fixture participant
root and reuses existing nym-bootstrap grant verification. It neither enrolls a
council nor grants current transport/revocation authority. Both whole gates and
optional stay-ready execution retain their partial scope.
The next clean Node 2928253c composition verifies 24/66 obligations through
59 native inspections, including ordinary A/A2 renewal on distinct nodes with
one rooted participant and one evaluated source. Forty-two obligations remain;
these are original heterogeneous runtime prefixes, not final A/B qualification.
A later SQLite cohort observes the reset lifecycle 2/1/2 with an unchanged first
pair. Its independent three-cut predicate additionally verifies the persisted
current read model; membership history cannot substitute for status-only cache
refresh. Clean-source verification and the Matrix counterpart remain pending.
This verification-only tooling does not change the adopted homeserver clock,
certificate policy, admission, signing, renewal authority or global readiness.
Clean Node 3eef910b subsequently verifies the original SQLite reset lifecycle:
complete before/revoked/replacement cuts, ordinary AD reset, signed old-source
revocation, replacement after the activation drain, unchanged first pair and
exact public current annotations. The full fresh prefix composition advances to
28/66 through71 native inspections;38 obligations remain. The current annotation
is independently checked through its owner and complete recorded basis, without
requiring status-only refresh to be a membership-history event. This scope does
not include the Matrix counterpart, final replay/privacy matrix, stay-ready
execution or loose/extracted/fresh-two-store equivalence. Whole A/B remain open.
Clean Node 9918b048 advances the fresh heterogeneous prefix inventory to 33/66
through 95 native inspections. The original Matrix A/A2 same-participant renewal
remains one source; the later A/A2/B reset has complete 2/1/2 cuts, signed
revocation, drained replacement, unchanged first pair and exact current annotations.
A later clean 4bf8df5a separate read-only whoami/sync observer and seven native
inspections verify all six original lifecycle PDU, stored export rows and author
buffers (maximum canonical PDU 9,305 bytes). Runtime still uses the explicitly
adopted authenticated-homeserver observation, without a runtime PDU-verifier claim.
Thirty-three obligations, full A/B and final two-store qualification remain open.
The new read-only media-control predicates do not close those gates by themselves.
The original strict media control/refusals at clean Node 91c43334 advance the
heterogeneous prefix composition to35/66 (102 native inspections). The owner's
subsequent local fixture image-backup adoption above requires a new positive
preflight; the inventory now has67 obligations. The original refusal and its
scope remain unchanged, without promoting it to the newly requested success.
Full A/B, effect-fenced optional renewal and final retained-store equivalence
remain open. The Node audit records exact process, tool and runtime provenance.
The owner-approved positive image-backup case is now observed at clean Node
37be7d02 / Orbidocs 16b1d962: backing/mounted OS exclusions remain false/true,
the explicitly named effective-view rule derives false, and the read-only native
preflight attests under allow-encrypted-image-backups. The strict case still
refuses. No provider/key is created in the empty image. Fresh composition600
verifies36/67, including that new requirement, through102 native inspections;
31 remain. Copies of image/keystore stay outside erasure assurances. This is
heterogeneous prefix verification; final A/B and both-store qualification remain
open. The later exact bb060dd8/92d0fe7b full software repeat passes9315/0/128;
it does not promote that original prefix to a complete runtime gate.
Explicit conformance composition — 2026-11-03¶
Clean Node c6f57910 / Orbidocs 92d0fe7b freshly composes42/67 obligations:
the prior36 runtime/native prefixes plus six separately classified component
conformance predicates. Exact named assertions, complete per-suite counters,
original source/process receipts and48 independently adopted schema byte pairs
are required. The schema-sync script's unit tests alone do not prove mirror
synchronization. The component tests keep their original 91c43334 / 4b50ef48
source identity, distinct from the newer predicate and runtime prefixes.
The whole profile remains partial:13 A and12 backend B obligations, optional stay-ready effects and final single-candidate/retained-store qualification remain. Conformance neither creates runtime HTTP observations nor closes either gate. The Node resumption audit and ledger own the exact command, review and result provenance. No source-profile parameters, authority or historical evidence change.
The later clean Node b212be6a prefix composition613 verifies43/67 through103
native calls. A/post-ack-erasure now binds the exact complete original explicit
SQL key/ciphertext inventory, signed closing status, owner-local ACK deadline and
metadata observed before recovering provider open. The current v2 snapshot is
not substituted for a compacted historical v1 context. This does not claim
physical-block erasure, backup-keystore destruction or whole-AD/Vault privacy.
Twelve A and12 backend B obligations remain; optional stay-ready execution, final
single-candidate A/B and loose/extracted/fresh two-store qualification remain open.
Independently verified source replay checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
Clean Node b7b2cf49 composition627 freshly verifies 45/67 obligations through
111 native inspections. Actual Matrix619 and SQLite622 restart after loss of only
the derived contextual cache and perform real owner replay. Original source,
admission, nonce, receipt, first-emission and history tables remain unchanged.
A separate ended-epoch/no-cache verifier checks the actual current readback; it
neither weakens fresh-view assertions nor supplies fresh active-epoch evidence.
Original fresh-only refusal624 remains preserved.
Twelve A authority/status/privacy and five B cases per backend remain. Runtime,
capture and verifier pins differ explicitly. The heterogeneous prefix inventory
does not close final single-candidate A/B or loose/extracted/fresh two-store
qualification. P015-001–003 and complete contextual authorship remain partial.
See node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#independent-original-backend-replay-qualification-2026-11-03.
The subsequent original631 controlled AD receiver cases observe rejection of
four encrypted invalid private requests, with no prepared decision or new target
context. Clean Node e75dd92a independently reinspects their valid baselines,
council offers and isolated faults in633. The temporary local source adapter is
explicit fault injection and is restored after D stops; it proves no INAC/network
authority. An expired anonymous first leg remains a separate narrower witness.
Process/input/effect qualification and recomposition are still required, so
coverage remains45/67 and both complete gates remain partial.
Independently qualified private receiver refusal checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
Clean Node f270f62a composition636 freshly verifies 49/67 obligations through
115 native inspections. Four original631 full-request refusals now have complete
process, exact input, AD receipt, offer/outbox/recipient and no-effect predicates.
No decision is prepared and no new issuer context appears. The temporary local
fault adapter is restored after D stops; this does not prove INAC authority.
The expired anonymous first leg remains separate from full-request expiry.
Eight A and five B cases per backend remain. Capture, runtime, fixture client,
native verifier and profile revisions are independently pinned. Final
single-candidate A/B, privacy and retained two-store equivalence remain open;
P015-001–003 and complete contextual authorship stay partial. Review:
node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#independent-original-private-ad-refusal-qualification-2026-11-03.
Independent original full private-request expiry checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
Clean Node 8d590a16 independently qualifies original638: a full, unchanged
private request and signed council key offer were valid when frozen; after the
original 30-second deadline, actual D runtime 103c8fae permanently rejected
that exact sealed buffer with expires/at: expired. No decision or new target
context was created. Owned cleanup and temporary local adapter restoration
completed. Capture, client and native verifier are pinned to clean 153932f9;
this controlled local AD refusal is distinct from INAC transport authority and
from the earlier narrower expired anonymous first leg.
Fresh composition641 covers 50/67 obligations through 116 native calls. Seven A authority/status/privacy obligations and five B obligations per backend remain open. The remaining B scope is late first receipt, collection/emission freshness, public privacy, retired acceptance environment and UI refusals. 273 Python profile tests, 24 native inspector tests, five negative-client tests and strict all-target Clippy for both affected crates pass without incremental compilation. Scoped headers and the light gate pass; a broader header migration audit separately refuses an existing unrelated Sensorium inventory mismatch, which this work leaves untouched. Final single-candidate A/B and fresh two-store retention remain unqualified. P015-001–003, full Whisper and global readiness retain their partial/bounded scopes; historical runtime evidence is unchanged.
Status-owner checkpoint (2026-11-03): original648 observed actual host S020
progression from signed revision4 to5, refused refresh of an older still-valid
status, and the retained higher HWM after A restart. Frozen native42 from clean
Node a2ae9913 freshly verifies original signatures/time/cursor in inspection650.
The complete process/proxy/HTTP/source-image predicate is still pending; this
adds no qualified coverage yet (50/67 remains). The final forward read was
cache-only and does not prove a completed healing fetch. Original647's ordinary
AD certificate and separate protected fixture recovery steps prepare these cases;
its ended fixture epoch is historical input, not new authoring authority. All
owned actors and the proxy stopped, and A's adoption was restored. P015 remains
partial; final A/B and retained two-store qualification remain open.
Independently qualified status-HWM checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
Complete qualification653 at clean Node bc480a7a binds original648's actual
A/D processes, S020 proxy response bytes, scoped HTTP reads and immutable source
images. It verifies signed revision4→5 progression, refusal of older still-valid
bytes and the higher retained HWM/API after A restart. Native42 independently
checks original signature/time/cursor semantics. Original652's discriminator
refusal is preserved; the correction requires canonical integer schema/v = 1.
The final cached forward read remains distinct from a completed healing fetch.
Fresh composition654 covers 52/67 obligations in 118 native calls. Five A cases and five B cases per backend remain open, along with final single-candidate A/B and fresh retention from both adopted stores. Tests: 282 Python profile and 25 native inspector cases, affected all-target Clippy, scoped headers and light gate pass without incremental compilation. No full historical runtime cohort is renewed. P015-001–003, full Whisper and global readiness retain partial/bounded scope. Owned A/D and proxy stopped and original A adoption was restored.
Independently qualified private-minimum checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
At clean Node 9e2c4dcb, independent665 verifies original664: ordinary renew
retains public floor1 while the local private minimum13 refuses still-valid
signed status12. Actual preview returns the typed status-revision-unavailable
503 and readback has no authoring result. After actual status15 arrives, the same
certificate signs the reviewed confidence0.5 document through the ordinary host;
readback preserves the exact signed record. Four native checks verify certificate,
both statuses and reviewed record. Exact source/process/HTTP/proxy pins, original
time windows and cleanup/restoration bind the controlled runtime. No private
decision plaintext is reconstructed. Earlier producer failures remain unchanged.
Fresh composition666 covers 53/67 obligations in 122 native calls. Four A
cases remain: wrong exchange digest, revoked bootstrap authority, status
equivocation and private AD/tombstone privacy. Five B cases per backend, final
single-candidate A/B and fresh retention from both adopted stores remain open.
All 297 Python profile tests and scoped headers/light gate pass. Runtime source
103c8fae is unchanged; no full historical runtime or software gate is renewed.
P015-001–003, full Whisper and global readiness retain partial/bounded scope.
Owned A/D and proxy stopped; original A adoption restored. No merge/push.
Independently qualified withdrawn-bootstrap checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
Clean Node b8dbfd76 inspection673 independently verifies original669: exact
valid INAC offer, signed active-to-revoked bootstrap authority, unlocked but
blocked issuer, actual403 before and after owned restart and absent issuer
reply/applicant certificate. Two native owner calls preserve the independently
adopted root and original times. The reason-only HTTP projection is retained
exactly and bound to separate captured coarse owner results; it is not expanded
into a claim of raw HTTP preservation. Original668 and672 coordinator failures
retain their original outcomes. Withdrawal is permanent, without reimport or
automatic authority replacement.
Fresh composition674 covers 54/67 obligations in 124 native calls over
8,446 logical reads/322,724,216 bytes; result SHA-256 is
0319cbfc5bc6d6796bc6540516f3440425ee778d3054ca6fd202367c456c10b7.
Three A cases remain (wrong exchange digest, status equivocation and private
AD/tombstone privacy), plus five B cases per backend, final single-candidate
qualification and fresh two-store retention. All310 Python profile tests pass;
the28 native and affected strict Clippy/paths evidence retains its stated source.
Native43 uses clean 85b8c9e3, without incremental; runtime 103c8fae is unchanged.
This does not renew the complete software/transport qualification or close
P015-001–003, either full gate, Whisper or release readiness. No merge/push.
Independently qualified status-equivocation checkpoint (2026-11-03)¶
Clean Node d14a3c89 inspection682 binds original681 actual host S020, exact
proxy response bodies, owner/control/process identities and four immutable
source images. Two correctly signed statuses have the same revision4 and
different canonical digests. The owner refuses the conflict before and after
A restart, preserving the original status, durable cursor and actual API view.
Three fresh native calls verify the certificate and both original-time conflict
transitions. Fixture-only operator signing and proxy adoption are restored;
no council key is exported. Native44 uses clean 107b436b, separately from
runtime 103c8fae and the later inspection source.
Fresh composition683 covers 55/67 obligations in127 native calls over
8,502 logical reads/323,488,096 bytes, with result SHA-256
bde6f2270965e6f786f96e7e8524fc17b9ec1994d50b296a17f4d156ad06d181.
The324 profile Python and29 native example tests, affected strict Clippy/paths,
scoped headers and light gate pass. At that checkpoint, two A cases remained
(wrong exchange digest and private AD/tombstone privacy), five B cases per backend, final single-candidate
qualification and fresh two-store retention. P015-001–003 and both full gates
retain their partial scope; no new full transport, software or release claim.
Original680 completes ordinary protected AD issue with two explicit recovery
exports. Original679 expiry and684 missing-decision outcomes remain failures.
For684, the correlated receiver row says expires/at: expired, while its AD
admission timestamp is5.274067 seconds before the original deadline. Exact
subsequent owner verification time is unknown. The earlier diagnostic's
arrival-after-expiry assumption is explicitly refused; the corrected source
snapshot/row correlation is retained separately. This does not qualify a
wrong-digest refusal or justify extending the signed deadline. Owned actors
are stopped, protected originals retained, and no merge/push occurs.
2026-11-03 private reply-binding implementation checkpoint¶
The earlier implementation checkpoint retained55/67 independently verified obligations. Controlled original694 now observes an otherwise valid council-signed coarse reply with a wrong private request digest being rejected by the actual applicant INAC acceptor. Decision and certificate remain absent after the owned applicant restart. Its independent profile closure was pending at that checkpoint; the later qualified checkpoint below resolves this one obligation, not either full gate. The current producer repair uses canonical Community ciphertext classification for both exchange senders. Earlier runtime source pins and failed attempts remain historical. See the Node resumption audit for exact source, control and verification boundaries; an acceptance-only signed-pair inspection is not runtime admission.
Independently qualified private-decision binding (2026-11-03)¶
Clean Node039b46ec inspection697 now qualifies A/wrong-exchange-digest from
original694. The profile binds actual owned A/D processes, authenticated controlled
AD submission, the exact INAC offer/notification/consent and sealed reply, the
stored typed applicant refusal, and unchanged absent decision/certificate after
restart. Later read-only source snapshots696 verify the exact original A/D
admissions without pretending to have been captured at the original admission
time. Native45 (cleanbe2781d6) freshly checks both council signatures, the anonymous
proof at original time and exact sealed public-recipient binding. It never
reconstructs the private request, decrypts, signs or creates admission.
Fresh composition698 verifies 56/67 obligations through128 native calls over
8,635 logical reads/344,823,251 bytes; result SHA-256
16a18e3144219707ee004bfa0368e7c9599c520f072a012f4537a2da9e33e2a8.
The339 profile conformance tests include corrupt/missing sources, rebound causes,
foreign owners, nonunique source identities and incomplete INAC/restart witnesses.
One A privacy obligation, five B obligations per backend, final current-candidate
qualification and identical fresh retained-store qualification remain.
P015-001--003 and both full gates stay partial; global Agora, full Whisper and
release readiness are unchanged. Earlier failed attempts and prefix-only claims
remain historical. No merge or push occurs.
Independently audited private storage (2026-11-04)¶
Clean Node73dc0288 composition703 now verifies 57/67 obligations, covering
all30 A predicates, through128 fresh native calls and9,204 logical reads/
393,710,364 bytes. Result SHA-256:
07263819db8740ecae49811dda153aaf18a63a7781daa24d60cda8578cece107.
A profile-owned bounded audit checks561 later AD/INAC/issuer source entries and
composes the original ordinary issue/reset/renew and post-ACK-erasure predicates.
These later source cuts do not become admission-time observations.
Private INAC authorization passports may name their beneficiary and authorization/ delegation subjects at four exact fields. That permission is confined to private transport metadata; it does not admit a participant-to-nym mapping, a private request/decision nonce, successor linkage or primary identity in public artifacts. The audit checks closed aggregate retention receipts and encrypted exchange buffers; it does not claim whole-Vault privacy or completeness of historical logs. No erasure guarantee for physical blocks or copied keystores is added.
351 profile tests and scoped source/light checks pass. The five B predicates per
backend, final clean current-candidate cohort and identical loose/extracted/
two-store qualification remain pending. All full gates and P015-001--003 remain
partial; neither global Agora nor release readiness is promoted. Existing
failed attempts and source-specific software results retain their exact scope.
See node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#private-adinac-storage-privacy-closure-2026-11-04.
The final source-boundary review rejects hidden/generated columns and user tables resembling SQLite internals; fresh703 repeats the full57-predicate closure under that guard. The earlier702 source-bound result remains historical and unchanged.
Actual late first SQLite reception (2026-11-04)¶
Clean Node61b27ba8 composition719 verifies 58/67 obligations (A30/30,
B22/31 and six conformance),132 fresh native calls and9,359 logical reads/
398,848,754 bytes. Result SHA-256:
d37a49f5ef00b0a160c708dcdd40caf4efb73ae3a19d36ef1483d1add0ac9ae4.
The separately qualified ordinary UI715 publication and later receiving716 bind
the same exact author bytes and signed SQLite receipt. Publication is within
certificate validity; actual first reception is after expiry plus5s and before
epoch end. The receiving process uses existing SDK owner ports with SystemClock;
it is not an HTTP import, another signer or an invented historical clock.
Later consistent snapshots and original process observations are independently
checked; close/reopen does not replace the separate restart/replay predicate.
361 profile tests and scoped source/light checks pass. The original decoder,
missing-command and expired-delivery refusals retain their original outcomes.
Nine B predicates remain: Matrix late receipt and collection/emission freshness,
public privacy, retired acceptance environment and UI refusals on each backend.
The final current-candidate cohort and identical loose/extracted/fresh two-store
qualification are still required. Optional stay-ready effects remain not-enabled;
P015-001--003 and both full gates remain partial. No full software, transport,
global Whisper or release qualification is renewed. See
node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#actual-late-first-sqlite-reception-2026-11-04.
Actual late Matrix reception (2026-11-04)¶
Clean Nodebf607f06 composition727 freshly verifies 59/67 obligations
(A30/30, B23/31 and six conformance),137 native calls and9,710 logical reads/
412,471,376 bytes. Result SHA-256:
f75c33d9ce748abecae8c40458a897dd2ca1871db2c363ad2a1050399473dc15.
Ordinary AD/protected host721 and confidence0.5 publication reach actual Synapse;
controlled503 sync/history refusal delays first C reception until after real
certificate expiry plus5s, before epoch end. Separate read-only observer723 and
complete9,317B room-v10 PDU724 bind exact author bytes, authenticated publication
time and original source/nonce to independently verified hashes/signature/size.
The controlled fault is not a homeserver failure; this is host/API authoring,
not another UI case. PDU verification is acceptance-only and adds no runtime
PDU verifier, portable time or federation guarantee.
All372 profile conformance tests and scoped source/light checks pass. Eight B
predicates remain: collection/emission freshness, public privacy, retired
acceptance environment and UI refusals on each backend. Final current-candidate
qualification and identical loose/extracted/fresh two-store retention remain
pending. Optional stay-ready effects remain not-enabled. Neither full gate,
P015-001--003, full Whisper/global Agora nor release readiness is promoted.
Original refusals and earlier source/software scopes stay unchanged. See
node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#actual-late-matrix-reception-2026-11-04.
Original SQLite collection/emission freshness (2026-11-04)¶
Clean Node51bf99a7c composition786 freshly verifies 60/67 obligations
(A30/30, B24/31 and six C conformance),146 native calls and10,661 logical
reads/455,448,168B. Result SHA-256:
11e641a0e860753e7c1fa3f7b7066e39e8649dcf9e88d68dd3745bab62fa59c7.
Candidate41 at d0af38a2f completes actual AD certification780A/782B with explicit
fixture recovery exports. Genuine signed issuer status9 permits collection but
returns status-stale for first emission. B then uses ordinary protected host
preview/sign/readback; SQLite201 admits the second source, with no first emission.
After controlled delivery releases genuine fresh status14, one signed
threshold/proposal pair appears. Independent785 rechecks original certification,
review, status and all three complete cuts in nine native calls.
The result journal tracks changed bases, not every refreshed status. The frozen
first threshold supplies the verified first status/time binding; the latest
changed current basis may still contain the older collection-only status. Shared
profile-owned host helpers preserve the already qualified late Matrix predicate.
All388 profile tests and the light/scoped source gates pass. Seven B requirements
remain: Matrix freshness, public privacy, retired acceptance environment and UI
refusals on both backends. Final current-candidate/full-software and identical
loose/extracted/fresh two-store qualification remain pending. Optional stay-ready
remains not-enabled. Both full gates, P015-001--003, full Whisper/global Agora and
release readiness retain their partial scope. No runtime PDU verifier, portable
Matrix time proof or federation qualification is added; historical evidence and
refusals remain unchanged. See
node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#independently-composed-sqlite-freshness-2026-11-04.
Independently composed both-backend freshness (2026-11-04)¶
Clean Nodee09459884 composition808 freshly verifies 61/67 obligations
(A30/30, B25/31 and six C conformance),163 native calls and11,576 logical
reads/498,753,839B. Result SHA-256:
fd6f4066022bec13ad5255da8ed1a3eec8a48b2ecca7babdf24fa06f2994b268.
Actual SQLite783 and Matrix802 distinguish collection from first-emission
freshness. Candidate/service42 at01378f863 completes ordinary AD799A/801B and
protected late host signing. Matrix202 reaches actual sync admission; signed
status8 permits two sources without first emission. After release, actual
delivery of signed11 precedes the single frozen threshold/proposal pair.
Separate read-only sync803 and a consistent PostgreSQL export804 bind all four
room-v10 PDUs (9,271/9,271/2,442/2,187B), original stored rows, exact author bytes
and unchanged independently adopted server keys. Native807 rechecks everything
in15 fresh calls.
Original793 remains a failed HTTP429 capture. Original805 retains its predicate
refusal: first-available10 and first-used11 legitimately differ. Review replaces
that false equality with monotonicity plus native verification of the actual
status response delivered before freeze, including its exact freshness window.
No lease, timer, admission or assertion limit is increased. All390 profile tests
and scoped/light gates pass. Six B requirements remain: public privacy, retired
acceptance environment and UI refusals on both backends. Final current-candidate
cohort, full final software and identical loose/extracted/fresh two-store retention
remain required. Optional stay-ready is not-enabled. Both full gates and
P015-001--003 remain partial. The phase-1 authenticated-homeserver clock and
acceptance-only PDU checks add no runtime PDU verifier, portable time or federation
claim; global Agora/Whisper/release scope is unchanged. See
node:docs/audits/WHISPER-AUTHORSHIP-RESUMPTION-2026-10-29.md#independently-composed-both-backend-freshness-2026-11-04.
Original UI refusal witnesses — 2026-11-04¶
Clean 6e5b2f134 captures812/813 observe the actual no-JS UI on the ordinary
protected A owner and C with SQLite and Matrix respectively. Each records
403 CSRF, 400 unreviewed publication, 409 retained-preview conflict and 409
new preview with a historical certificate/ended epoch. The final refusal has
an original typed nym-status-epoch-retired owner diagnostic; this is not an
isolated certificate-expiry measurement. The original signed result remains
identical. A positive health request proves the relay monitor is active; the
closed UI lifetime contains no publication request. Consistent before/after
SQLite backups independently show unchanged authoring rows, relay records
and publication requests. Credentials and complete form bodies stay private.
Independent814 initially omitted the four original unlock occurrences from its
manifest and refused. Independent815 reached the original backup but exposed
a reader bug: SQLite deserialize() cannot read a WAL-mode backup without
its WAL. Both refusals and original images remain unchanged. ad57184df
uses an immutable read-only temporary file without rewriting the original
WAL header; a real WAL backup regression passes. Independent816 now freshly
verifies both original UI cases, including ordinary AD certification and
native review/signature checks. This changes the verifier, not runtime results.
Complete fresh composition817 verifies 63/67 (A30/30, B27/31 and six C
conformance),167 native calls and12,763 logical reads/568,813,335 bytes.
Its result SHA-256 is 41b9a6703caaac371842b07ac1eecaea787147ac0f1e32b237ddd2dee7cb5adc. The 401 profile tests,
scoped headers and diff checks pass; the preceding new predicate also passed
the light workspace gate. Four B predicates remain: public privacy and retired
acceptance environment inertness on each backend. Full current-cohort/software
and identical loose/extracted/fresh qualification from both stores remain open.
Optional stay-ready is not enabled or runtime-qualified. No final A/B/global,
archive publication, merge, push or protected-material cleanup claim is made.
Explicit retired-environment runtime and full software gate — 2026-11-04¶
The 3ff8ed68b capturer supplies the four fixed retired Whisper selectors to
the actual ordinary applicant child after stripping ambient legacy variables.
Original AD820/SQLite821 and AD840/Matrix841 use the protected Vault, ordinary
private certification, confidence0.5 and genuine backend admission. Independent
829 verifies SQLite; independent847 verifies unchanged Matrix840/841,
read-only843 and complete PDU844 in five fresh native calls. The full PDU is
9,311 bytes and preserves the exact author buffer. This tests the contextual
owner under explicit selectors; it does not claim to execute a removed legacy
intake signer. The separate historical-intake checks remain conformance.
The original824/AD822 refusal remains: the first key request received
nym-issuer-status-maintenance-due. The later834/AD832 source first received
nym-issuer-context-capacity-exceeded, then expired. The fixture permits only
one active context. Normal S020 closed the previous context at07:02:10,
after that request's expiry. New842 checks the already closed source state
before minting its new request; the read-only fixture check is advisory, and
ordinary admission still owns the decision. No context capacity, profile, retry
or request deadline was increased. AD840 completed in79.12s. The Matrix841 stage (owner startup, status,
publication and reception) took11.85s. These are observations from this run,
not latency bounds.
Original845 independently refused because its predicate compared the signed
author value to the locally stamped source record. 43cc273d9 reuses the existing
conversion removing exactly the three unsigned relay facts; other differences
still refuse. A real-shape Matrix regression and408 profile tests pass. Native
input/output bindings are now included in both new proof families. No original
runtime, author buffer, PDU or failed qualification was rewritten.
Full workspace gate818 passed on exact clean 3ff8ed68b: Clippy/all targets,
9,319 passed, zero failed,128 explicitly ignored, formatting, ledger/retention
and path checks. Cargo was nonincremental. The later qualifier-only change has
408 profile tests and a passing light gate; Rust/Cargo inputs were unchanged.
Fresh composition848 verifies 65/67 (A30/30, B29/31 and six C conformance),
175 native calls and13,902 logical reads/627,498,895 bytes. Its result SHA-256
is 5c0e24dbfd13ae8b59d12a3ae43b2c6d01ffdc76e4d7352e7841ad070c7d71df. These repeated logical reads are not archive size.
The two remaining B predicates concern public privacy on SQLite and Matrix. Final scope reconciliation and identical loose/extracted/fresh qualification in both stores remain mandatory. Optional stay-ready is not enabled or qualified. No full A/B, global Agora/Whisper, release, archive-publication, merge or push claim follows from this checkpoint.
Original public-surface privacy composition — 2026-11-04¶
Clean Node 035dd627c freshly composes 67/67 obligations (A30/30,
B31/31, six conformance), using179 native calls and13,979 logical reads.
Original ordinary AD856 renewal and SQLite857 controls are completed by the
read-only UI861 continuation. New ordinary AD862/Matrix863 has six nonempty
API/UI/detail/topic/SSE controls, independent read-only sync865 and complete
PDU866 (9,281 canonical bytes), original stored row and exact author bytes.
Full PDU verification remains acceptance-only under the adopted phase-1 clock.
The predicate independently binds original owner processes, closure, record controls and backend admission. Actual fixture participant, primary public-key and source-node canaries cover semantic JSON/HTML/URI/SSE and decoded v2 author buffers. Protected canaries use only byte length and digest, with bounded work; no secret value, Vault key or recovery bundle enters these controls. A fresh verified reset predicate owns the positive historical old-nym witness; current record/detail/SSE/author/PDU observations cannot link it. Private AD authority metadata and operator notification reads retain their separate access classes. An empty notification list does not invent a public Whisper notification emitter.
Original readiness, clock-unlock503, CSRF-capture, expired-preflight and witness
adoption refusals remain intact. A later read-only continuation does not turn a
failed capture into success. Review corrected typed refusal preservation,
secret-window limits, process/clock substitution and missing UI-pin refusal;
427 profile tests pass. No Rust/Cargo input changed after the already-passed
full gate818 on clean 3ff8ed68b (9,319/0/128 ignored, nonincremental).
Fresh873 result SHA-256:
4b2f1906c602d49d7ed28bf0a91fad316e83a7ddf455400104bb1a4ed5afcb4b.
The complete proof inventory is still not final A/B qualification. Original scope/current-cohort reconciliation, exact public retention dependencies and identical loose/extracted/fresh qualification from both stores within the unchanged budgets remain required. Optional stay-ready is not enabled or runtime-qualified. P015-001--003, full Whisper/global Agora and release retain their partial scopes. No archive publication, merge or push occurred. See the Node running audit.
Campaign custody and cleanup owner decisions — 2026-11-04¶
For P015-003 only, necessary isolated fixture-owner database images and private
capture dependencies may use an audited operator-only profile in the adopted
private primary/replica stores. Git retains path-free metadata. Keystores, keys,
passwords, live credentials and recovery bundles remain excluded; byte limits do
not change. This resolves the public/private custody choice, without approving
unaudited contents or completing the remaining qualification.
The owner permits removal of unused producer-owned artifacts after actual ownership, active-use and dependency checks. Required A/B inputs, user data, keys, parallel work and worktrees remain protected. After A/B adjudication, a reviewed withdrawal of large evidence may retain only revisions, scope, original results, conclusions and an exact deletion inventory. Affected availability and loss of requalification must be explicit. The permission cannot promote an unfinished gate. Node's bounded cleanup review records removal of inactive Cargo cache only; campaign evidence remains intact.
Witnessed SQLite admission profile (2026-10-29)¶
The new whisper-source-profile.v2 selects
publication/sqlite-time-policy = witnessed-admission-receipt-v1. It binds the
receipt key-window and five-second commit budget, plus exact authorized signing
use tuples. Version one remains unchanged and its SQLite time policy is
unsupported by the portable admission consumer. Auxiliary manifest signatures
have their own domain and do not grant publication. Receipt snapshot history
establishes admission-relative status, not retroactive compromise time.
P035-019 supplies this bounded input contract and receiving-side tuple matcher;
it does not qualify the P015-005 issuer exchange. The existing decision-v1
runtime cannot carry the extended certificate and explicitly returns
UnsupportedProfile before issuer effects. A versioned issuance exchange is
required before operators can obtain these grants through that runtime.
Synthetic signed fixtures qualify the P035 producer and historical consumer,
without claiming notice issuance or the complete P015-005 gate.
Transitional material-origin profile v3 (2026-11-05)¶
The new closed source profile v3 independently admits exact uses of signal v2
and v3. Certificate v3 retains the existing NymCertificate v1 signature framing;
its scope/content-schemas is exactly [whisper-signal.v2, whisper-signal.v3].
Recognizing a new schema does not authorize it under an older profile. Exact
profile and certificate use tuples remain mandatory. A new issuance exchange v2
binds the new profile; historical exchange v1 and signed artifacts keep their
original preimages and meaning.
publication/window-start and publication/window-end delimit one half-open
epoch: start equals epoch/anchor plus an integral multiple of epoch/seconds,
end equals start plus epoch/seconds. Production remains limited to seven days.
Certificate and document validity cannot cross end. At end, new issuance,
preview, sign and first publication refuse for every producer using this
profile, including v2 producers. Clock skew never extends the window. Original
event-time verification and committed historical reads remain available.
A production adoption is a separate owner decision, outside the Sensorium milestone. It requires named receivers with confirmed profile/certificate support and explicit acceptance of cutting off the others, including their v2 reception. Other producers must migrate within the single window or the owner must accept the resulting publication outage. A new digest changes context and source/ref; renewal, thresholds and room proposals do not automatically bridge profiles. Existing rooms retain their own lifecycle. Case succession currently refuses a profile transition. Another window therefore needs a separate continuity assessment, not automatic rollover.
Signal v3 carries all four whisper-origin.v1 fields at its root. Receivers admit
all current author classes with the complete origin vocabulary; restrictions on
Harvester production (derived-local only) do not restrict recipient law. The
summary is independent of source counting and never asserts independent
corroboration. This contract checkpoint is not runtime Gate A/B qualification.
Issuance v2 integration checkpoint¶
The anonymous key-request/key-offer bootstrap remains v1 and binds the exact adopted profile digest. Full participant requests and council decisions use separate v2 plaintext and sealed families under profile v3. Request v2 fixes the v2/v3 content vocabulary; it does not grant those uses. Profile and certificate exact-use admission still decides authority. Participant, nym and bootstrap proofs and council decisions have distinct v2 signing domains. Certificate signing retains the NymCertificate v1 framing.
Current carrier adapters accept the closed six-phase envelope vocabulary and check the exact selected phase; original v1 contracts are unchanged. The AD prepared-phase owner keeps ciphertext, input identity and readback together. Retained reply lookup creates no new signature or validity after window end. Profile v2 retains historical parsing and its separate status lifecycle; new issuance for it remains refused. This integration is not fresh Gate A/B evidence or production adoption.
Local readback/delivery and applicant/issuer offer inputs have new closed v2 shapes. Current routes bind named version unions, including offline OpenAPI closure, instead of widening any historical v1 contract. Actor, phase, profile and existing key-recovery admission remain separate owner checks.
Protected common-review and current-status continuation (2026-11-05)¶
The separate authoring preview/sign/readback v2 contracts select an exact current Harvester review. The host supplies approved text, topic, polarity, derived-local authorship and origin. Caller publication parameters cannot replace them. Sign rechecks review and custody after key unlock; first publication independently checks the retained candidate and existing AD holds. Historical signed readback does not authorize a new publication or renew an expired profile window.
Source-status request v2 accepts certificate v3 under the unchanged status-result contract. Current routes use the named exact v1/v2 request union; the original certificate-v1 request is unchanged. Actual profile/issuer, clock and signed status admission remain mandatory. This removes a closed-request mismatch rather than using schema recognition as authority. Fresh A/B for this continuation is open; the phase-1 result keeps its original source, profile and scope.
Bootstrap-v2 implementation and issuer checkpoint (2026-11-06)¶
The accepted separate template is implemented in pure capability law, mirrored schemas, local request/consent owners, offline root ceremony and independent native grant/revocation inspection. An absent local revision selector preserves v1; explicit v2 selects the new singleton before delegate creation. Both live consent owners derive the selector from the adopted full exchange. Current component selection requires 74 named assertions and 96 mirrored schema pairs.
An ordinary encrypted-owner attempt reached D with the full v2 request but
refused at local consent. Source analysis identifies the old v1-only parent as
the incompatible authority; original generic refusal bytes remain unchanged.
The correction does not reinterpret that parent or reuse the expired case. Fresh
ordinary issuance and two-backend Gate A/B remain open, with no production
adoption. Exact prerequisite/refusal scope is recorded in
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-ISSUER-AUTHORITY-20261106.md.
First ordinary v3 certificate checkpoint (2026-11-06)¶
A fresh ordinary encrypted-owner fixture has issued a v3 certificate over all
four exact TLS/AD phases using separately signed bootstrap-v2 authority.
Independent native inspection verifies A/issue and A/reference-readback.
Together with fresh same-source R/C/W7/native inputs, the campaign is now
20/131 verified with 111 missing; ordinary/optimized results agree. Original
reports/refusals remain preserved, with process inventory added only in a
separately bound derived view. No Whisper was signed or published.
A separate 128 MiB capacity observation stopped after 2479 retains with an
untyped host cause; a complete DB/WAL copy passes integrity checks. It grants
no load/recovery credit. Full signed SQLite/Synapse, all-producer window-end,
recipient/privacy and remaining load/fault qualification remains open. Existing
P084/P078 and dependent owner trackers stay in progress. This does not adopt
production or renew historical evidence. See
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-FIRST-ISSUANCE-20261106.md.
First reviewed Matrix publication and status-cache withdrawal (2026-11-06)¶
The source-bound Sensorium fixture independently verifies A's private AD certificate, reviewed protected v3 UI signing and Matrix HTTP 202/public readback. Its separately pinned campaign reaches 21/131, with 110 missing and identical ordinary/optimized results. B fails startup before export: status-cache compaction requires a formerly adopted profile absent from current configuration. C is reaped; no common-receiver, threshold, complete-PDU or full A/B credit follows. The earlier SQLite 22/131 retains its separate source and result.
The owner correction validates retained canonical bytes, digest and source links
before withholding unadopted status. It preserves facts and existing budgets,
refuses current use without adoption and restores signature/cursor verification
only on exact readoption. Other adopted profiles can operate and missing
projections can rebuild; corruption remains a refusal. Component regressions
pass and the next v3 conformance selection requires both withdrawal/corruption
assertions. Fresh current-source native/runtime and Matrix qualification remain
open; no historical gate or production adoption is renewed. See
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-FIRST-MATRIX-PUBLICATION-20261106.md
and node:daemon/docs/CONTEXTUAL-NYM-CERTIFICATION.md.
Scoped reviewed-v3 Matrix first pair (2026-11-07)¶
The source-bound fixture now verifies two ordinary AD certifications and reviewed v3 publications, an independent C/D first pair, persisted post-expiry evaluation and exact full-PDU delivery through a separate read-only client. The owner cache withdrawal repair has live positive B startup and both named conformance controls. A historical C read after the window closes is retained separately; it does not qualify all-producer refusal or old-node v2 cutoff. Full Gate A/B remains open.
The independently composed campaign verifies 25/131, with 106 missing,
and identical ordinary/optimized incomplete results. Runtime/capture Node
985964ee83 / Orbidocs 2b5ea4fd and corrected reader Node d83a9a0f remain
separately pinned. Both original reader refusals and every source observation are
preserved; no certification/publication retry, production adoption or historical
gate renewal follows. Current implementation evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-MATRIX-FIRST-PAIR-20261107.md.
Later 2026-11-07 fixture replica/window checkpoint¶
The source-bound campaign now verifies 29/131, with 102 missing, identically
in ordinary and optimized readers. Exact-predecessor A2 renewal on a distinct
registered node of A's participant retains one source and no first emission at
independent C. A newly started C reads the same signed records after the single
aligned window ends. Runtime 985964ee83 / 2b5ea4fd, capture 845bf6f7 /
ca9b73c9 and window reader fb4301fb remain separate pins. Earlier source-bound
reports and the original four-PDU scope remain unchanged.
This adds two replica/source-count and two window/history obligations. It does
not qualify certificate-at-boundary, all-producer end refusal, old-node v2 cutoff,
complete public/P082 direct-peer/Room/gossip privacy or full Gate A/B. Production
is not adopted. The remaining fixture matrix and existing parent trackers stay
open; another profile digest does not automatically preserve source continuity.
Current implementation evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-REPLICA-WINDOW-20261107.md.
Later 2026-11-07 SQLite/late-receipt checkpoint¶
The SQLite/late-receipt fixture checkpoint verifies 32/131, with 99 missing, identically in ordinary and optimized readers. One reviewed Harvester v3 owner completed protected UI preview/sign across restart, SQLite publication (201) and a signed receipt. A new SDK receiving store first admitted the exact original author bytes/receipt after certificate expiry plus skew, using the real clock, and retained its facts across close/reopen. This is not an HTTP import, common SQLite threshold/room proof, second publication or full Gate A/B.
Runtime 985964ee83 / 2b5ea4fd, capture fe7c595e / 65a4b8a3, receiver
build 2995a9f7 and final reader ba4a235b stay separate. All previous29
original predicates reverify. The earlier wrong-backend runtime refusal,
unattempted late SDK, incomplete reader and empty-stderr campaign refusal remain
preserved; corrections use new cases or read-only views, without retrying an
uncertain publication. Backend readiness now precedes certification. The bounded
thirteen-root retention review leaves all217 exact-copy candidates blocked;
no retirement action or production adoption occurred. Parent trackers and the
remaining99 obligations stay open, including all-producer end refusal, boundary/
old-node-v2 cutoff and full P082/gossip privacy.
Current implementation evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-SQLITE-LATE-RECEIPT-20261107.md.
Native owner-policy checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
The native policy checkpoint verifies 37/131, with 94 missing, identically in ordinary and optimized readers, exit 2. All previous32 original predicates reverify. Five native AD/P091 obligations add inactive/complete adoption, editorial versus normative factory identity, separate ceiling refusal and unchanged old claim terms. Eleven actual system-clock stages include restored controls and owner reopen; three coherently rehashed scratch substitutions each refuse and restore the original positive.
Native build 190552c41, capture a8933630 and final reader 714e0bc10 remain
separate from existing runtime 985964ee83 / normative 2b5ea4fd. Original
rehearsals, cold-WAL collector refusal and hold-field reader refusal remain
preserved; the successful runtime was not repeated for reader correction.
Full gates and production adoption remain open, and parent statuses are unchanged.
These policy rows add no issuance, key/media or certificate-window qualification.
Finite fixture authority remains separate from standing operator consent.
Policy checkpoint evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-NATIVE-POLICY-20261107.md.
Native claim and transfer checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
The native claim checkpoint verifies 41/131, with 90 missing, identically
in ordinary and optimized readers (incomplete, exit 2). All previous37 original
predicates reverify. Four native AD obligations add same-key parameter conflict,
overlapping concurrent retain and lost-response reopen/retry, atomic transfer/
claim/first-result commit, and explicit live extension with real expiry controls.
Four coherently rehashed scratch substitutions each refuse with a restored
original positive. The native build/capture 069e95bbd and corrected reader
b7d0d6fc8 stay separate from unchanged runtime 985964ee83 / normative
2b5ea4fd; the original reader expiry-model refusal remains preserved.
No issuance, signing or media authority is exercised. Standing consent does
not extend finite fixture grants.
Full gates and production adoption remain open; parent statuses are unchanged.
Claim checkpoint evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-NATIVE-CLAIMS-20261107.md.
Native legacy checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
The native legacy checkpoint verified 43/131, with 88 missing,
identically in ordinary and optimized readers (incomplete, exit 2). All previous41
predicates reverify. Two native AD rows add digest collision/monotonic interest
through ordinary release, actual expiry/sweep and unadopted reopen, plus explicit
native operator-method release with a withdrawn admission witness. Same-object,
managed-only GC and healthy controls establish the causes; four rehashed scratch
substitutions each refuse and restore the original. Native build/capture/reader
6fcf49a3d / 35c23a9c remains separate from runtime 985964ee83 / normative
2b5ea4fd. Both pre-effect preparation refusals remain preserved.
No issuance/signing/media authority is exercised or renewed; finite grants
remain separate from standing operator consent.
Full gates and production remain open; parent statuses are unchanged.
Legacy checkpoint evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-NATIVE-LEGACY-20261107.md.
Original bytes and explicit revalidation checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
At this original-byte checkpoint the campaign verified 48/131, with 83 missing, identically in ordinary and optimized readers (incomplete, exit 2). All previous 43 cases reverify. Five composed predicates cover exact original transfer/inline representation custody, actual gzip and typed ISO-8859-2 refusal without handoff, original-preserved extractor omissions, acquisition horizons and three explicit 304 through delayed review, restart and replay. Two owners are reaped; no unsolicited fetch or renewed claim occurs. Six coherently rehashed controls per mode each refuse then restore original positives. 73 Python tests per mode pass.
Capture dade45982 and corrected reader 945a2bf9c / Orbidocs e37021ad remain
separate from the pinned runtime 985964ee83 / normative 2b5ea4fd. The original
capture runs once; three reader precondition refusals remain preserved. No
production Rust, schema or capability contract changed. Ten-root catalog/dry-run
review records 158 selected files/6264441 bytes, seven exact duplicate-output
candidates 1767461 bytes and zero eligible. Active 48 evidence/authority remains
protected; no retained deletion/move/retirement authorization/execution occurred.
No issuer key/grant/recovery operation was needed. Certificate boundary, protected custody holds and all-producer window end remain open.
Full gates and production remain open; parent statuses are unchanged.
Original-byte checkpoint evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-ORIGINAL-BYTES-20261107.md.
Finding origin and adopted monitoring checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
The original-input campaign verifies 51/131, with 80 missing, identically in ordinary and optimized readers (incomplete, exit 2). All previous 48 cases reverify. Three new rows cover all nine canonical finding-class mappings, non-web Sensorium/mixed material, and collection bound to an adopted configuration after its real 60-second interval. Thirteen immutable reviews replay across an actual owner restart, with two web snapshots and four exact custody refs. Scalar metadata cannot create web, monitoring or model lineage. These synthetic operator-inline finding classes imply no mail/filesystem/device acquisition or signed author-class reception. Scheduler is disabled; due execution is explicit.
Collector/reader bfb0d90b0 / Orbidocs f2abbe21 remain separate from runtime
985964ee83 / normative 2b5ea4fd. Six coherently rehashed controls per mode
refuse, each followed by a restored-original positive; 82 Python tests per mode
pass. The original capture is unchanged and runs once. Six-root catalog/dry-run
review records 138 selected files/4863454 bytes, three duplicate-output candidates
1294585 bytes and zero eligible. Active qualification and authority dependencies
remain protected; no retained deletion/move/retirement authorization/execution.
These numbers are run observations, not contract thresholds.
Full processing/inference provenance, signed v2 absence versus v3 unknown,
author-class reception, mixed authorship holds, clock/load/fault, all-producer
window/cutoff, P082/gossip privacy and full two-backend gates remain open. Parent
statuses and production adoption are unchanged.
Current measured evidence: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-ORIGIN-MONITORING-20261107.md.
Manual v2 authoring under exact-use profiles (2026-11-07)¶
Manual signal-v2 authoring retains preview/sign/readback v1 commands. Historical
certificate-v1 replies retain nym-authorship-readback.local.v1 byte semantics.
An exact-use source profile (v2 or transitional v3) returns the new closed
nym-authorship-readback.local.v3: its document remains signal v2, while its
certificate is exactly certificate v2 or v3. The three manual routes declare
nym-authorship-readback-response.local.v1, a named union of the historical and
new reply contracts. Historical contracts are not widened or relabelled.
The review-selected signal-v3 path keeps local readback v2 and its mandatory review binding. Manual v2 cannot supply an origin-v3 draft through this adapter. Profile/certificate use, current status and the half-open publication window remain owner admission conditions; recognizing the reply is not permission. This repair follows an actual fixture response-contract refusal after a successful reviewed-v3 publication. It is not all-producer end-window qualification.
Exact SQLite renew and bounded window review (2026-11-07)¶
Independent ordinary/optimized readers on runtime 653eac2b / Orbidocs
be10c3bc verify A2 exact-predecessor renew, the completed A/A2 C/D same-source
group and 21 actual post-window refusals across A/A2/B and v2/v3, with native
signed inputs, positive controls and historical readback. The prepare descriptor
remains valid beyond window end. The later A/B S020 launch refusal and a fresh A
status-refresh owner failure remain unresolved; the original parent campaigns
stay refused. Closed host diagnostics preserve safe causes without new retries
or authority. No complete A/B post-certificate-expiry claim or full current-source
campaign credit follows. Historical 51/131 belongs to its original runtime;
parent trackers and production adoption remain open. Scoped implementation review:
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-RENEW-WINDOW-20261107.md.
Post-issue S020 fixture checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
An ordinary private-AD issue followed by four actual S020 freshness cycles passes
independent ordinary/optimized signature and exact-launch readers on runtime
aa36c538 / capture d028ac8b / Orbidocs 79240ab8. This diagnostic adds no
registered rows. A separate runtime 653eac2b aggregate re-executes 6/131, with
125 missing; it must not be added to the historical 51/131 on another runtime.
The original shutdown/wait refusals remain preserved. Complete A/B independent
C/D post-certificate-expiry continuation, full Gate A/B and production adoption
remain open. Details and retention limits:
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-S020-CHECKPOINT-20261107.md.
Ordinary renewal/window continuation (2026-11-07)¶
Node runtime/capture b8c45e5dd with Orbidocs 8588f942 independently verifies
A issue, exact predecessor-bound A2 renew and both reviewed-v3 SQLite publications
(201). Fourteen separate A/A2 v2/v3 end-window refusals and four signed unpublished
controls pass native inspection; protected historical reads remain available.
The whole R35 campaign stays refused: B's final request records twelve
nym-issuer-busy refusals then expiry, and a separate C/D attempt stops at C's
nym-status-refresh-unavailable after a successful issuer launch. No complete
receiver/expiry contribution, full Gate A/B or production claim follows.
Follow-up bounded phase/timing diagnostics and source-readiness waiting preserve
policy and wire errors;
they have no fresh runtime qualification. Exact sources, retained failures and
retention limits: node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-ORDINARY-COHORT-20261107.md.
Receiver and closed-window checkpoint (2026-11-07)¶
Node runtime/capture 78911310 and Orbidocs 7a3a3b4f independently re-execute
7/131 requirements (124 missing), identically with ordinary and optimized readers.
A issue, exact predecessor-bound A2 renew and B issue each publish reviewed v3
through the ordinary SQLite UI. C verifies one source across A/A2; actual A/B
reception produces a threshold and Room proposal after correcting the fixture's
effective exact consumer list. Operator status access is a separate authority
boundary from a supervised module's live channel.
The original R37 parent refuses during post-certificate-expiry S020 polling:
the selected D job is interrupted after 17231 ms against 9999 ms; its refresh
takes 14313 ms. This is not complete contribution-after-expiry qualification.
Separate 21 all-producer v2/v3 end-window refusals and a before-end-adopted,
after-end four-record C read pass native ordinary/optimized inspection. No failed
parent is relabelled, no historical runtime counts are added, and full Gates A/B
and production adoption remain open. A follow-up removes duplicate constructor
recovery in the existing single slot, preserving profile, capacity and media
guards; its native qualification remains open. Exact identities and limits:
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-RECEPTION-WINDOW-20261107.md.
Exact-renew readiness checkpoint (2026-11-08)¶
The runtime056 R38 parent remains refused: A publishes reviewed v3, while A2's
exact renew records busy admission followed by original-request expiry. No
complete C/D or post-certificate-expiry contribution follows. A Python fixture
prerequisite now binds A's actual predecessor and observes fresh S020 status
before preparing A2, without changing a prepared deadline or any owner lease.
All 566 regressions and six focused normal/optimized controls pass; native
qualification of this orchestration change is still open. The independent
runtime789 seven-of-131 subset is not transferred to a new source. Exact scope:
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-RENEW-READINESS-20261108.md.
Paused qualification checkpoint (2026-11-08)¶
R39 independently verifies 9/131 (122 missing) on retained runtime056 and
capture8b07, identically with ordinary/optimized readers. Exact A2 renew,
same-source and independent A/B reception, ordinary UI/receipts, all-producer
window refusals and historical C read pass. The complete post-certificate-expiry
proof correctly refuses: outer S020 success contains no-work and the retained
evaluation is stale. Unchanged public records do not establish that subclaim.
Work is paused at the owner's request; no new window or production adoption.
The original runtime and reader results remain unchanged. Resume basis:
node:docs/evidence/sensorium-web/SENSORIUM-WEB-V3-RENEW-RECEPTION-20261108.md.
Explicit ADC source transfer component (2026-11-18)¶
The existing local case workflow now accepts only adopted profile/certification/
authoring-operation references for retain-adc-consent. Actual source/Vault and
S026 owners transfer the complete retained consent and approved payload/opening
without a private JSON export, fresh signature or status fetch. The saved scope
binding supports exact replay; current actor/root/disclosure and profile adoption
remain gates. This uses the collection-status budget for private retention, not
a new first-emission permission. Native holds/egress and complete issuance/runtime
qualification remain under P015-005-ADC and ADC-001/003/004/005.