Przejdź do treści

Corpus Reasoning Experiment Review v4

Source schema: doc/schemas/corpus-reasoning-experiment-review.v4.schema.json

A reviewer's signed verdict over exactly one typed experiment proposal: its ref and digest and the exact candidate artifact it carries. evidence-state/digest names the evidence the reviewer saw, the executed-run records published to the Room, in place of the Story 012 terminal snapshot. A reviewer never supplies a replacement candidate: request-regeneration asks the solver for a new candidate, which is a new proposal that needs its own review. Whether a review, a Chair decision and a proposal belong together is decided by the Corpus relation gate, not by this schema.

Governing Basis

Project Lineage

Stories

Fields

Field Required Shape Description
schema/v yes const: 4
review/ref yes string
query/id yes string
room/id yes string
proposal/ref yes string
proposal/digest yes string
candidate yes ref: corpus-reasoning-experiment-proposal.v2.schema.json#/$defs/candidate
reviewer yes ref: corpus-reasoning-room-policy.v1.schema.json#/$defs/room-subject
reviewer/node-id yes string
reviewer-turn/id yes string
evidence-state/digest yes string
verdict yes enum: accept, reject, request-regeneration
findings yes array
reviewed/patches no ref: corpus-task-pack-review-verdict.v1.schema.json#/$defs/patches Exact review claims covered by this signature. Historical reviews may omit them; new task-pack repair admission and recipe publication require complete coverage at the owning relation gate. Absence is never enriched into historical coverage.
class/key yes enum: Public, Community, Personal
reviewed-at yes string
expires-at yes string
idempotency/key yes string
signature yes ref: corpus-reasoning-experiment-proposal.v1.schema.json#/$defs/signature
## Field Semantics

schema/v

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: const: 4

review/ref

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

query/id

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

room/id

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

proposal/ref

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

proposal/digest

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

candidate

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: ref: corpus-reasoning-experiment-proposal.v2.schema.json#/$defs/candidate

reviewer

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: ref: corpus-reasoning-room-policy.v1.schema.json#/$defs/room-subject

reviewer/node-id

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

reviewer-turn/id

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

evidence-state/digest

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

verdict

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: enum: accept, reject, request-regeneration

findings

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: array

reviewed/patches

  • Required: no
  • Shape: ref: corpus-task-pack-review-verdict.v1.schema.json#/$defs/patches

Exact review claims covered by this signature. Historical reviews may omit them; new task-pack repair admission and recipe publication require complete coverage at the owning relation gate. Absence is never enriched into historical coverage.

class/key

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: enum: Public, Community, Personal

reviewed-at

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

expires-at

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

idempotency/key

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: string

signature

  • Required: yes
  • Shape: ref: corpus-reasoning-experiment-proposal.v1.schema.json#/$defs/signature